IPA Newspack
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets

IPA /

IPA Special

IPA Special

Shiv Sena Battle In Supreme Court Between Uddhav And Shinde May Be Prolonged

By Indira Jaising

At the hearing of the Maharashtra political stalemate before the Supreme Court bench comprising the Chief Justice of India (‘CJI’), N.V. Ramana, and Justices Krishna Murari and Hima Kohli on August 3, arguments commenced with senior counsel addressing the court on the questions of law arising for consideration in the Sunil Prabhu batch of petitions under Article 32 of the Constitution.

The issue squarely posed for decision by the Supreme Court by senior counsel, Kapil Sibal is whether the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution recognizes only two grounds to invite disqualification, namely, Paragraph 2(a) read with the explanation, that is, voluntarily giving up membership of the original political party, which is the political party on which the elected legislator stood for elections, and Paragraph (2)(b), that is, voting contrary to the party whip.

At the outset, it is worth reiterating that the object of the Tenth Schedule is to prevent defections during the five-year tenure of an elected legislator, and not the other way round, namely to find ways and means of defecting, and avoiding disqualification.

In the facts of this case, given that we now have two whips, which one is the Speaker bound to follow for the purpose of Para 2(b)?

The Solicitor General of India, Tushar Mehta, presented his questions of law on behalf of the Governor of Maharashtra. He agreed with senior counsel Harish Salve that disputed questions have to be decided by the Speaker and not by the court.

The bench requested Salve to reformulate his questions of law for clarity. His main argument appeared to be that the petition filed by Shiv Sena legislator Prabhu of the Uddhav Thackeray faction was not maintainable.

To this, the CJI asked, “Who approached the court first?” The answer was obviously Maharashtra Chief Minister Eknath Shinde, who first invoked the jurisdiction of the court and obtained an order granting his faction time to reply to the show cause notices issued by the Deputy Speaker. This delay enabled the Shinde camp to make a round trip from Mumbai to Surat to Guwahati to Goa back to Mumbai. It was thereafter that Shinde and the Bharatiya Janata Party’s (‘BJP’) former Maharashtra Chief Minister and current Deputy Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis staked a claim to form a government. The rest is history.

The former Lok Sabha Secretary-General, P.D.T Achary, explains that the issue before the Supreme Court in this case, is something different. He told The Leaflet: “In my opinion, the only question for a decision by the Supreme Court is who has the power to issue a party whip? There are two whips, one issued by the Eknath Shinde faction and one by the designated party whip of the Shiv Sena. The speaker has no power to decide the question; only the Supreme Court can decide. “

In other words, this promises to be a two-stage hearing: the question of law is to first be decided by the Supreme Court, and once the power to issue the party whip is decided, then the question of disqualification will be decided by the incumbent Speaker.

Although the Solicitor General, appearing for the Governor, stated that this is not an extraordinary situation, according to Achary, “it is extraordinary as for the first time we have two whips. The Speaker cannot decide this issue; it is unprecedented.”In  such   a situation, the Supreme Court will decide what the speaker is expected to do. It remains   to be seen how the SC frames its own questions.

One thing is clear: the case is headed to a five-judge bench, as it undoubtedly involves a question of interpretation of the Constitution. It is equally clear that given that the current Chief Justice is retiring on August 26, it will not be decided by a bench presided over by him.

The Shinde government will survive, if it does politically, on the orders of the court with an uneasy uncertain status quo. The pendency of the petition partly explains the inability to form a full Cabinet.

The Thackeray camp has asked for a stay of proceedings before the Election Commission as any decision will impact the pending case, and the decisions may become irreversible.

The Election Commission is faced with a unique situation where there are no two factions, and Thackeray continues as the President of the party. As no one has staked a claim to be the President of the party nor is it claimed that there are two separate parties claiming the election symbol, it is unclear what the Election Commission is expected to decide and how.

These, and other related issues, will have to be decided before Shinde gets the stamp of legitimate Chief Minister of Maharashtra. He does, however, continue to be the de facto Chief Minister until another intra-party fight breaks out this time between the BJP and the Chief Minister over the spoils of office. (IPA Service)

Courtesy: The Leaflet

IPA Special

BJP Leaders Have Started Course For Overthrow Of Nitish Kumar Regime

August 17, 2022
IPA Special

Decoding My Seventy-Two Years In Independent India-Part Two

August 17, 2022
IPA Special

Reining In ‘Freebies’ Needs Thorough Debate

August 17, 2022
IPA Special

Release Of The Eleven Imprisoned Rapists Of Bilkis Bano Is Atrocious

August 17, 2022
IPA Special

Heyday For Geopolitics Of Eurasian Transport

August 17, 2022
IPA Special

Jagdeep Dhankar Had A Chequered Career Involving Many Political Parties

August 17, 2022
IPA Special

NATO Expansion Into Finland And Sweden A Danger To World Peace

August 17, 2022
Happening Now

DMK moves Supreme Court over ‘freebies’ term scope

August 17, 2022
Politics

R’sthan Cong Rs 20 lakh aid for slain Dalit boy’s family

August 17, 2022
Politics

Gehlot vs Pilot fight resumes ahead of polls next year

August 17, 2022
Happening Now

Azad quits J&K Cong panel within hours of appointment

August 17, 2022
Happening Now

Meira Kumar says ‘Chamar’ used as slur against her father

August 17, 2022
IPA Special

Prime Minister’s Five Pledges On Independence Day Mean Very Little To Poor

August 16, 2022
IPA Special

Labour Movement Has Lost Its Earlier Striking Power

August 16, 2022
IPA Special

Decoding My Seventy-Two Years In Independent India

August 16, 2022
IPA Special

Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s ‘Achhe Din’ Now Needs 25 Years More

August 16, 2022
IPA Special

Donald Trump Is On Dock Over FBI Seizures Of Classified Documents From His House

August 16, 2022
IPA Special

Bihar Developments Are Going To Have Impact In Uttar Pradesh In 2024 Polls

August 16, 2022
IPA Special

Amrit Mahotsava Has Been Turned Into A Big Jumla By Sangh Parivar

August 16, 2022
IPA Special

For Global Arms Dealers, Russian War In Ukraine Is A Big Bonanza

August 16, 2022

An appeal

The legacy of IPA, founded by Nikhil Chakravartty, the doyen of journalism in India, to keep the flag of independent media flying high, is facing the threat of extinction due to the effect of the Covid pandemic. Only an emergency funding can avert such an eventuality. We appeal to all those who believe in the freedom of expression to contribute to this noble cause.
Click here to learn more

Share

Reply

  • 0
More on IPA

BJP Leaders Have Started Course For Overthrow Of Nitish Kumar Regime

August 17, 2022 3:33 pm | IPA Staff

  By Arun Srivastava   It was certainly not a coincidence that on the day Prime   Minister was addressing the Independence   Day rally, Amit Shah...

IPA Special

Decoding My Seventy-Two Years In Independent India-Part Two

August 17, 2022 3:32 pm | IPA Staff

  By Nitya Chakraborty   In 1960, at the global level, the most important development was the World Conference of the   communist parties, the result...

IPA Special

Reining In ‘Freebies’ Needs Thorough Debate

August 17, 2022 3:30 pm | IPA Staff

By Dr. Gyan Pathak   The ongoing freebies case in the Supreme Court of India has reached an interesting stage with the DMK seeking to...

IPA Special

Release Of The Eleven Imprisoned Rapists Of Bilkis Bano Is Atrocious

August 17, 2022 3:30 pm | IPA Staff

By Sushil Kutty   Monday, the eleven   persons   who gang-raped Bilkis Bano during the 2002 Gujarat communal riots walked free. The panel that let them...

IPA Special

BJP Leaders Have Started Course For Overthrow Of Nitish Kumar Regime

in IPA Special
Aug 17, 2022   ·  

Decoding My Seventy-Two Years In Independent India-Part Two

in IPA Special
Aug 17, 2022   ·  

Reining In ‘Freebies’ Needs Thorough Debate

in IPA Special
Aug 17, 2022   ·  

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Follow us on
Up Next: Remembering August 6, 1945 For First Atomic Bombing On Hiroshima
©2020 -2021 India Press Agency, All Rights Reserved
Newspack by India Press Agency
Posting....
logo
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets