IPA Newspack
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets

IPA /

IPA Special

IPA Special

Karnataka Shows Bipolar Contests Enabler Of Opposition Victory

By Harihar Swarup

What are some of the implications of the Congress’s emphasis and creditable win in Karnataka for national politics? At one level it would be unwise to extrapolate from state to national elections. The logic of these elections is not always aligned. Nevertheless, the Karnataka results has implications for how we understand the evolution of national politics.

The first and perhaps most important lesson is that BJP will find it, in most places, harder to win genuinely bipolar contests, where third parties in the state decline. This is for a simple reason that in a bi-polar contest, the BJP has to polarize more of Hindu votes and in some cases, as many as, 50 per cent to win. Even in most communalized of states that is a tall order. Not all the J D (S) votes shifted to the BJP. But the fact is that the Karnataka elections became de facto less tri-polar. So the question is, whether this condition can be successfully replicated elsewhere, not just at the level of a state but the local level. This is no guarantee of success. But de facto bipolar contests are at least one of the enabler for an opposition victory.

The second trend to observe is that the Opposition’s best hope is to chip away at BJP’s governance. The Karnataka BJP had scored too many own goals for it to be rescued. It did more or less everything wrong. It has a chief ministerial face, who did not have a mass base or even command over the party. Increasingly, the BJP is going to face this challenge. The theory of the BJP model, like the model of good governance in all regional parties that have endured, is not to reduce corruption. The model is to centralize corruption. This also has the advantage of cutting out intermediaries for most services. You can then combine this with a couple of schemes to project good governance. Increasingly, the BJP is finding it hard to hold onto this aspiration and getting stuck in the quicksand of intermediaries. Part of this is driven by venality, as politics often is; but part of this is driven by the need to placate different constituencies (as we are increasingly seen in Haryana). This also makes it vulnerable. As the party expands, it paradoxically becomes more brittle at the state level. But this will also be a challenge to the incoming Congress government.

The third lesson is the consistent welfare story. One of the most remarkable shifts in Indian politics has been the expansion of the welfare state. This has different fiscal implications in different states. Frankly, these are far more significant than caste, which was often an endogenous response to the absence of any other form of politics. But most states now have fiscal resources to send creditable welfare signals to their constituents. This is true across all states, from Ashok Gehlot in Rajasthan to Mamata Banerjee in Bengal and Naveen Patnaik in Odisha. Much of this welfarism is for good; it is universal in character, mostly directed at goods and forms of fiscal support that are empowering and should be looking at as long-term investments, rather than as handouts.

The fourth lesson is the clear divide between the politics of privilege and the politics of the poor. One of the remarkable things about the Congress victory in Karnataka is that support for it cuts across classes. But, at least, in Karnataka, there is overwhelming evidence that the minorities, the socially and economically marginally groups supported the Congress in far greater proportion. The big question is whether this divide portends a national fault that can be exploited. Or rather the question to be asked is under what conditions the messaging can this become a national fault line?

The fifth reason is that it is too immature to talk of the repudiation of Hindutva by Karnataka voters. There is a rather simplistic binary that we often use: Was it Hindutva or was it governance? This is an unproductive way of posing the question. Political competition is about creating credibility on a broad front. If the BJP had administratively governed better, Hindutva would have been consolidated as a consequence. You could pose the question the other way round. Despite a government that, by all account, was a disaster, the BJP has still managed to hold onto its vote share in Karnataka. Even in a campaign where everything went wrong, the long-term changes the BJP has brought about in cultural preferences should worry us. The most you can say is that just Hindutva alone will help you retain a base but not push you over the margins of victory. This is small comfort. But it will not be enough to secure either Karnataka or India from the rising tide of communalism.

The sixth lesson is that political identities are not over-determined by social identity. Even the success of Hindutva was premised on unsetting existing social identities, and exploiting the opportunities provided by the individualization of the voter. (IPA Service)

Politics

DMK to coordinate opposition unity efforts: Stalin

June 1, 2023
Politics

Modi blasts Cong for misleading poor, ‘guarantee habit’

June 1, 2023
Happening Now

Gehlot adds free power to pre-poll promises

June 1, 2023
Politics

Rahul holds session with Silicon Valley AI experts, entrepreneurs

June 1, 2023
Happening Now

Farmers call Khap Mahapanchayat for wrestlers

June 1, 2023
IPA Special

US Govt Putting Pressure On India To Join NATO+ As A Part Of Asia-Pacific Strategy

May 31, 2023
IPA Special

Political Outcome From Communal Cauldron May Not Favour BJP

May 31, 2023
IPA Special

No Real Truce Is Ready At Ending Gehlot-Pilot Infighting In Rajasthan Congress

May 31, 2023
IPA Special

Slowdown In Containerized Exports Poses Setback To Pro-Export Agenda

May 31, 2023
IPA Special

Sons Of First Joint Climbers Of Mount Everest Are Carrying The Legacy Of Their Fathers

May 31, 2023
IPA Special

Shiites And Not Jews Emerge As Touchstone Of Saudi Moderation

May 31, 2023
IPA Special

Kerala Govt To Move SC Against Centre’s Cut In Net Borrowings Ceiling

May 31, 2023
IPA Special

G7 Conclave Fails To Meet Commitment For Nuclear Weapons Abolition

May 31, 2023
IPA Special

Defection Of Lone Congress MLA In Bengal To TMC Angers Alliance Partner CPI(M)

May 31, 2023
Politics

Gehlot, Pilot patch-up success increasingly in doubt

May 31, 2023
Happening Now

World body condemns action against Indian wrestlers

May 31, 2023
Politics

Yechury appeals to Cong to supports AAP on ordinance

May 31, 2023
Politics

Mamata says Shah trip prompted by her own visit plan

May 31, 2023
Happening Now

Owaisi dares Centre to strike on China instead of Telangana

May 31, 2023
IPA Special

NITI Aayog Has Failed To Play Any Effective Role In Planning For Indian Economy

May 30, 2023

An appeal

The legacy of IPA, founded by Nikhil Chakravartty, the doyen of journalism in India, to keep the flag of independent media flying high, is facing the threat of extinction due to the effect of the Covid pandemic. Only an emergency funding can avert such an eventuality. We appeal to all those who believe in the freedom of expression to contribute to this noble cause.
Click here to learn more

Share

Reply

  • 0
More on IPA

US Govt Putting Pressure On India To Join NATO+ As A Part Of Asia-Pacific Strategy

May 31, 2023 3:56 pm | IPA Staff

By Arun Srivastava Narendra Modi’s yearning to be acknowledged as the world leader (Vishwa Guru) has landed India in a unpleasant quagmire endangering its identity...

IPA Special

Political Outcome From Communal Cauldron May Not Favour BJP

May 31, 2023 3:55 pm | IPA Staff

By Dr. Gyan Pathak BJP has broken its legs in Karnataka   assembly polls when it fell into the pitfalls of majority politics. The party, including...

IPA Special

No Real Truce Is Ready At Ending Gehlot-Pilot Infighting In Rajasthan Congress

May 31, 2023 3:09 pm | IPA Staff

By Sushil Kutty The latest Sachin Pilot-Ashok Gehlot patch-up will last till June 8 when disqualified Congress Member of Parliament Rahul Gandhi returns from his...

IPA Special

Slowdown In Containerized Exports Poses Setback To Pro-Export Agenda

May 31, 2023 1:44 pm | IPA Staff

By K Raveendran There is a marked slowdown in the containerized exports from India, attributed mainly to a decline in consumer demand for Indian goods...

IPA Special

US Govt Putting Pressure On India To Join NATO+ As A Part Of Asia-Pacific Strategy

in IPA Special
May 31, 2023   ·  

Political Outcome From Communal Cauldron May Not Favour BJP

in IPA Special
May 31, 2023   ·  

No Real Truce Is Ready At Ending Gehlot-Pilot Infighting In Rajasthan Congress

in IPA Special
May 31, 2023   ·  

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Follow us on
Up Next: Pilot camp reminded of plight of past party deserters
©2020 -2021 India Press Agency, All Rights Reserved.
Newspack by India Press Agency | Statement of Ownership | Contact Us
logo
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets