IPA Newspack
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets

IPA /

IPA Special

IPA Special

Contradictory Trends In Supreme Court Orders Give Cause For Concern

By Prakash Karat

Two judgments delivered by the Supreme Court in the course of a week have brought out starkly the contradictory trends on display in the highest court of the land.

In the case of the multiple FIRs against Alt News journalist, Mohammed Zubair, a three-member bench consisting of Justice D Y Chandrachud, Justice Surya Kant and Justice A S Bopanna, in their judgment asserted that the power to arrest must be used sparingly subject strictly to the law and guidelines laid down by the top court in the Arnesh Kumar case.  The judgment stated that “Arrest is not meant to be and must not be used as a punitive tool because it results in one of the gravest possible consequences emanating from criminal law: the loss of personal liberty”.

With this judgment, the Supreme Court struck a vital blow against the arbitrary use of police powers and defended the fundamental rights of citizens. This is what is expected from the Supreme Court which has to act in defence of the constitution.

However, two days later, another judgment has been delivered by a three-member bench on a batch of petitions challenging the constitutional validity of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002.  The judgment delivered by the bench consisting of Justice A M Khanwilkar, Justice Dinesh Maheshwari and Justice C T Ravi Kumar had upheld all the provisions of the law which give sweeping powers to the Enforcement Directorate (ED) that do not follow the provisions of the CrPC for search, seizure, arrest and attachment of properties. The court has endorsed the definition that the ED is not “police” and therefore does not have to follow the provisions of the CrPC. This means that a statement made by an accused to ED officials is admissible in court unlike a statement made before a police officer, which is inadmissible.

The court has also upheld the twin conditions for bail for which the accused has to make a case that he or she is prima facie not guilty of the offence and also satisfy the court that they will not commit any further offence. This places the onus of proof of not being guilty on the accused. The court has also stated that the supply of the Enforcement Case Information Report (ECIR) copy to the accused is not mandatory as it is an internal document, unlike the accused being entitled to a copy of the FIR filed by the police. Other draconian provisions which enable the ED to act in an arbitrary fashion have been upheld.

By this verdict, the court has legitimised a serious assault on the civil liberties of citizens who can be subject to arbitrary arrest, attachment of property and denial of bail. This regressive judgment shows how increasingly the apex court is becoming an executive court.

The disturbing fact is that the regressive trend is gaining ground even though there are instances of the court taking steps to safeguard constitutional rights from a rampaging executive.  One of the worst judgments in recent times was delivered by the same three-member bench headed by Justice Khanwilkar on an appeal proffered by Zakia Jafri and co-petitioner, Teesta Setalvad, in the Gulburg society case.

While rejecting the appeal, the bench proceeded to make unwanted references to the intention of some persons, by stating that, “She (Zakia Jafri) was obviously doing so under dictation of someone” which, according to former Supreme Court judge, Madan Lokur, is by innuendo accusing Teesta who had helped Zakia Jafri throughout her battle for justice for her murdered husband, Ehsan Jafri.  The judges then proceed to state that some people have sought “to keep the pot boiling, obviously for ulterior design. As a matter of fact, all those involved in such abuse of process need to be in the dock and proceeded with in accordance with law”.  Thus the court gave a virtual licence to the Gujarat police to arrest the co-petitioner in the appeal to the Supreme Court, Teesta Setalvad, without even having heard her side of the matter in the case.

The higher judiciary is under siege. All sorts of efforts are on to subvert the judiciary, starting from executive interference in the appointment of judges. Recently, adverse oral remarks made by a two-member bench of the court against the conduct of former BJP spokesperson, Nupur Sharma, let loose a torrent of abuse and calumny against the two judges in the social media and the sanghi press.

The warning is clear – fall in with ways of the authoritarian-communal regime.  The citizens of the country will fervently hope that the institution of the higher judiciary will be able to hold fast and withstand these threats with courage and fortitude.  (IPA Service)

Courtesy: People’s Democracy

Happening Now

China seeks urgent meeting after Lanka bows to Indian pressure

August 8, 2022
Politics

Akhilesh to start Tiranga campaign with padayatra

August 8, 2022
Politics

UP minister says he is ready to go to jail for his community

August 8, 2022
Politics

Gehlot’s rape remark kicks up row

August 8, 2022
Happening Now

Speculation over Nitish Kumar walking out of BJP alliance

August 8, 2022
Politics

BJP launches drive to woo minorities in Uttar Pradesh

August 7, 2022
Happening Now

Maiden launch of new ISRO rocket runs into trouble

August 7, 2022
Politics

Parliament ‘dysfunctional’, says Chidambaram

August 7, 2022
Politics

Dhankhar’s victory margin highest since 1997

August 7, 2022
Politics

Opposition parties see a new dawn for Congress in Bihar

August 7, 2022
Politics

Modi says proud moment for India to have ‘kisan putra VP’

August 6, 2022
IPA Special

National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme Being Sabotaged

August 6, 2022
IPA Special

Supreme Court Finds ‘Shackles Of Policy’ Put By Govt As Intimidating

August 6, 2022
IPA Special

More Tightening Of Monetary Policy May Not Be Effective At The Moment

August 6, 2022
IPA Special

Congress Is Under Seige By The Modi Government And It Will Continue

August 6, 2022
IPA Special

Narendra Modi Is Making All Efforts To Make India ‘Opposition Mukta’

August 6, 2022
IPA Special

Some Semblance Of Normalcy Is Returning To Kashmir At Long Last

August 6, 2022
IPA Special

Drones And Transport Capable Of Reshaping Eurasian Geopolitics

August 6, 2022
Politics

Buzz over Mamata’s meeting with Modi in Delhi

August 6, 2022
Happening Now

Amit Shah says Cong protest has anti-Ram temple message

August 6, 2022

An appeal

The legacy of IPA, founded by Nikhil Chakravartty, the doyen of journalism in India, to keep the flag of independent media flying high, is facing the threat of extinction due to the effect of the Covid pandemic. Only an emergency funding can avert such an eventuality. We appeal to all those who believe in the freedom of expression to contribute to this noble cause.
Click here to learn more

Share

Reply

  • 0
More on IPA

National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme Being Sabotaged

August 6, 2022 3:53 pm | IPA Staff

  By Gyan Pathak   The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme, popularly known as MGNREGA scheme is systematically being sabotaged. It is being...

IPA Special

Supreme Court Finds ‘Shackles Of Policy’ Put By Govt As Intimidating

August 6, 2022 3:52 pm | IPA Staff

  By K Raveendran   With the Modi government increasingly citing ‘policy’ to justify what it is doing, the Supreme Court has felt compelled to...

IPA Special

More Tightening Of Monetary Policy May Not Be Effective At The Moment

August 6, 2022 3:36 pm | IPA Staff

By Dr. Nilanjan Banik   Over the last two weeks, the Opposition is disrupting the Lok Sabha on the grounds of high LPG price and...

IPA Special

Congress Is Under Seige By The Modi Government And It Will Continue

August 6, 2022 3:19 pm | IPA Staff

By Sushil Kutty   Men and women in black. The women outdoing the men in scaling police barricades. Especially Priyanka Gandhi Vadra. The nationwide protests...

IPA Special

National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme Being Sabotaged

in IPA Special
Aug 6, 2022   ·  

Supreme Court Finds ‘Shackles Of Policy’ Put By Govt As Intimidating

in IPA Special
Aug 6, 2022   ·  

More Tightening Of Monetary Policy May Not Be Effective At The Moment

in IPA Special
Aug 6, 2022   ·  

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Follow us on
Up Next: Indian People Are Looking Forward To President Murmu With High Hopes
©2020 -2021 India Press Agency, All Rights Reserved
Newspack by India Press Agency
Posting....
logo
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets