IPA Newspack
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets

IPA /

IPA Special

IPA Special

A Gross Misunderstanding Of Language Led To Rahul’s Conviction

By Dr. Gyan Pathak

What is ‘understanding’ an utterance and what is ‘misunderstanding’? The answer is obvious – if someone understands exactly the same as to what was uttered is ‘understanding’ and if someone derives any other meaning is ‘misunderstanding’. Congress MP Rahul Gandhi’s conviction for two years of imprisonment with a fine of Rs 15,000 is clearly a case of ‘misunderstanding’ his utterance which was in fact targeted against Prime Minister Narendra Modi as a public servant who love to be called himself Pradhan Sevak of the Country, but not understood as such by one complainant BJP MLA and former minister of Gujarat Purnesh Modi and Chief Judicial Magistrate of Surat H H Varma.

At the end, the damage has been done. Lok Sabha secretariat has disqualified the Congress member from Wayanad of Kerala  state from membership as a result of the conviction and  the politico-legal war  will follow making  the functioning of  the Parliament, which is in session, impossible. But still, it is necessary to go into the details of what actually was the complaint and how the learned CJM arrived   at his’ bizarre’ decision as the noted lawyer Kapil Sibal said.

The complainant believed that Rahul Gandhi offended him and the judicial magistrate found that complainant was true in his submission, found Rahul Gandhi guilty of criminal defamation under section 499 and 500 of IPC and awarded him the sentence on March 23, 2023. Here, no amount of logic can justify that both the complainant and the judicial magistrate really understood Rahul’s utterance, and hence the judgement based on misunderstanding of an utterance is not a judgement at all but merely a decision from the seat of judgement.

Before going into merit and demerit of the case one needs to understand what constitute a meaning of an utterance keeping always in mind that no one is free to derive meaning other than what was really said, or else it would be a grave error leading to misunderstanding. Though there are many theories to understand the true meaning of an utterance – such as in semantics, semiotics, philosophy of language, metaphysics, metasemantics, psychological theories, logical theories, correspondence theory, coherence theory, constructive theory, consensus theory, and pragmatics theory in linguistics etc – one does not need to go through all of them to know the meaning of Rahul’s utterance.

Moreover, there is no need, and no one could be compelled, even by a judgement of a court, that Rahul Gandhi didn’t actually target PM Modi but  another Modi who was even unknown to Rahul Gandhi, as the complainant complained and the judicial magistrate believed. Had they known the simple fact that an utterance cannot be divorced from its context, they could not have landed into such a grave misunderstanding.

Let us put the matter straight. Rahul’s utterance came during an election rally in Karnataka on April 13, 2019. One can recall, at that time there were several fugitives, surnamed Modi who had committed offence and fled even outside the country while PM Narendra Modi were ruling the country. There were also allegations against PM Modi and his government that they had been supporting their favourite business persons and industrialists and BJP leaders were resorting to even nepotism.

A language and its usage are decided by the context in which they are uttered and no one has power over it. It was therefore but natural of a leader in opposition to ask questions or raise probing fingers on the leader of the ruling establishment who had come on the promise of making the country free of corruption, but increasing number of fraudsters were becoming fugitives with overt and covert support of the ruling establishment. Modi himself was alleged for corruption and lobbying for a favourite industrialist in the Rafale deal.

Rahul Gandhi had said, “Achha, ek Chhota sa sawaal, in sab ke naam, in sab choron ke naam, Modi Modi Modi kaise hai? Nirav Modi, Lalit Modi, Narendra Modi. Aur abhi thoda dhoondenge to aur bahut saare Modi niklenge.” (OK, one small question, in the name of all these, in the name of all thieves, how it come Modi Modi Modi? Nirav Modi, Lalit Modi, Narendra Modi. If search a little more many more Modi would come out.)

Meaning and target was clear, in which the complainant was not referred to even remotely. And no one has right to derive meaning whatever one like to, since such derivation lead us into a domain of “misunderstanding.” Gujarat court has fist derived wrong meaning and then convicted the utterer who did not mean that for which he was convicted. It is a judicial wrong.

Now come to legal point of view regarding meaning of an utterance and when it becomes a defamation. Even by simply going through the Chapter XXI of the Indian Penal Code, in which defamation was legally defined and it was also explained what does not constitute defamation, it is clear that a general statement for many cannot be termed defamation for an individual, more so when one is not remotely referred to. For example, if one says that Man is selfish, or Money is theft, he can not be convicted on complaint of a person that he was defamed by labelling him selfish or thief.

Moreover, no person can be held guilty of defamation when one asks a question to the audience, for an answer or for consideration of a burning issue. Rahul Gandhi has a right to campaign, and bring issues to electorate for their consideration while exercising their vote. It is a common thing in democracy that the opposition and ruling establishment trade charges with each other while addressing electorate appealing them to exercise their voting rights carefully.

It must also be noted that the complainant is a BJP leader and former minister of Gujarat. Though he had filed the case on April 16, 2019, he had given a second though to his action, and was himself convinced that filing the case was his over-reaction. However, he was not allowed to withdraw the case. Consequently, last year he had reportedly sought a stay from the High Court of Gujarat which was granted on March 7, 2022.  However, he again went to High Court on February 16, 2023, seeking vacation of the stay which was granted. Trial then resumed on February 27, 2023, before the new CJM HH Varma who gave his judgement on March 23, 2023, with lightning speed.

The whole issue does not seem to be fair, but a judge has a right to deliver a judgement, even a wrong one, that could be challenged in the appellate higher courts who has responsibility to correct the errors in the judgement. There might be much more in this issue than what has appeared on the surface.

Another issue of the very desirability of the defamation law in a democracy is under question. In democracy, a critical view of a political party or leader against others must not be considered defamatory.  (IPA Service)

 

IPA Special

Karnataka Election Results Have Given The Congress Some Useful Lessons

May 27, 2023
IPA Special

Forced Labour In India Highest In The World At Present

May 27, 2023
IPA Special

China All Set To Extend Its Solar Dominance To Global Wind Energy Sector

May 27, 2023
IPA Special

Greece Heads For Second National Elections As Coalition Talks Fail

May 27, 2023
IPA Special

Culture Wars Bubble Below The Surface Across Arab Region

May 27, 2023
IPA Special

Remembering Tina Turner, The Unapologetic Queen Of Rock And Roll

May 27, 2023
Politics

Six CMs staying away from PM’s NITI Aayog meeting

May 27, 2023
Politics

Cong poses 9 inconvenient questions to PM Modi

May 27, 2023
Politics

Cooperative federalism turned into joke, Kejriwal to Modi

May 27, 2023
Politics

BJP dares Karnataka govt to ban RSS, Bajrang Dal

May 27, 2023
Politics

Row over ‘The Diary of West Bengal’ film awaiting release

May 27, 2023
IPA Special

Opposition Politics In India Changing Fast In Next Few Months

May 26, 2023
IPA Special

Approval Of MiCA Regulation Leads To A New Dawn For Cryptocurrencies In EU

May 26, 2023
IPA Special

Under Nitish’s Leadership, Joint Opposition Slowly Takes Shape

May 26, 2023
IPA Special

Exchange Rate Depreciation Leads To Lowering Of The Real Wages Rate

May 26, 2023
IPA Special

Sourav Ganguly Has Given A Signal By Accepting Position Of BJP Govt Of Tripura

May 26, 2023
IPA Special

Tina Turner Was The Ultimate Live Performer Who Mesmerised People For Decades

May 26, 2023
IPA Special

Bernie Sanders And Chicago Mayor Johnson Have Come Out In Support Of Biden As Presidential Candidate

May 26, 2023
IPA Special

‘Succession’ Is US Television’s Most Devastating Critique Of The Ultrarich

May 26, 2023
Politics

Cong stand on Delhi ordinance depends on Punjab unit

May 26, 2023

An appeal

The legacy of IPA, founded by Nikhil Chakravartty, the doyen of journalism in India, to keep the flag of independent media flying high, is facing the threat of extinction due to the effect of the Covid pandemic. Only an emergency funding can avert such an eventuality. We appeal to all those who believe in the freedom of expression to contribute to this noble cause.
Click here to learn more

Share

Reply

  • 0
More on IPA

Karnataka Election Results Have Given The Congress Some Useful Lessons

May 27, 2023 3:58 pm | IPA Staff

By Harihar Swarup What are some of the implications of the Congress’s emphasis and creditable win in Karnataka for national politics? At one level it...

IPA Special

Forced Labour In India Highest In The World At Present

May 27, 2023 3:56 pm | IPA Staff

By Dr. Gyan Pathak Forced labour in India is the highest in the world. About 11 million are presently under forced labour in the country,...

IPA Special

China All Set To Extend Its Solar Dominance To Global Wind Energy Sector

May 27, 2023 1:15 pm | IPA Staff

By K Raveendran After establishing complete dominance in global solar supply chain, China is all set to maintain a firm grip of the global wind...

IPA Special

Greece Heads For Second National Elections As Coalition Talks Fail

May 27, 2023 1:09 pm | IPA Staff

By Satyaki Chakraborty Greece is heading for another general elections next month, possibly on June 25 as the ruling National Democracy Party refused to form...

IPA Special

Karnataka Election Results Have Given The Congress Some Useful Lessons

in IPA Special
May 27, 2023   ·  

Forced Labour In India Highest In The World At Present

in IPA Special
May 27, 2023   ·  

China All Set To Extend Its Solar Dominance To Global Wind Energy Sector

in IPA Special
May 27, 2023   ·  

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Follow us on
Up Next: Fight For A Prosperous Secular India Is The Best Tribute To Shaheed Bhagat Singh
©2020 -2021 India Press Agency, All Rights Reserved.
Newspack by India Press Agency | Statement of Ownership | Contact Us
logo
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets