By Raju Kumar
BHOPAL: The government is celebrating Janjatiya Gaurav Divas and honouring the sacrifices and struggles of tribal leaders, even as tribal families continue to face official indifference to issues concerning their land, livelihoods and forests. When the government introduced the Forest Rights Act twenty years ago, it acknowledged the historical injustice suffered by tribal and other traditional forest dwellers. Recognising their rights over forests was meant to help redress that injustice. Twenty years on, many families still have to prove their right to their own land.
Lok Swashasan Andolan recently held a public hearing in Bhopal on the implementation of the Forest Rights Act in Madhya Pradesh. Representatives of tribal and other forest-dependent communities shared the problems they face. Tribals account for around 21 per cent of the state’s population, yet their own institutions continue to have a limited say in how village boundaries are drawn, what evidence is accepted in deciding their claims and who manages their forests.
Meanwhile, forest rights are increasingly viewed in terms of government scheme targets and beneficiary counts. The Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Gram Utkarsh Abhiyan emphasises faster disposal of claims, dedicated forest rights cells and technical assistance. Such assistance can help villages gather documents and prepare maps. The question is whether the Gram Sabha or outside agencies will set the priorities for forest management plans. If Gram Sabhas have less room to make decisions, processing more claims will do little to strengthen community rights over forests.
The experience with the Van Mitra portal shows what this means for claimants. Madhya Pradesh launched the portal in 2019 to review previously rejected claims. The aim was to re-examine earlier decisions and make the process more transparent. Yet many claimants came to rely on kiosk operators or panchayat secretaries to file their applications and check their status. Some had their claims rejected again and received no written explanation. How can claimants challenge a decision if they have no way of knowing which evidence was considered insufficient or what was found lacking in their claim?
Sahariya representatives from Gwalior–Chambal said Gram Sabha meetings were convened at the panchayat level instead of in individual settlements. In some places, patwaris and beat guards were also made members of Forest Rights Committees. In Dindori, villagers raised concerns about the conversion of forest villages into revenue villages. They said their Gram Sabha was left out of the process of redrawing the boundaries and that some land used by the village was left off the new map. The question of habitat rights for the Baiga, Sahariya and Bharia communities is broader still. Alongside the land on which they farm and live, shared areas sustain their livelihoods and cultural life.
People from Ratapani, Panna, Durgavati and Satpura spoke about relocation in the name of wildlife conservation and restrictions on access to forests. Their testimonies raise a basic question about ‘voluntary relocation’. If it becomes harder for families to earn a living from the forest while staying in their village, and their access to basic services is also restricted, how voluntary is their decision to leave? People from areas affected by the Ken–Betwa and Narmada Valley projects raised questions about changes in forest land use, Gram Sabha consent and compensation. In some areas, villagers said plantations intended to compensate for forest clearing had been established on land they used for farming or other shared purposes.
The Forest Rights Act gave Gram Sabhas a central role in the claims process. It also recognised villages’ rights to conserve and manage forests. In many places, however, the Forest Department continues to exercise much the same control as before. Some families who have filed claims are treated as encroachers on the very land they claim. In some places, the department digs trenches around their fields. In others, it fences off the land and plants trees. There are also reports of families receiving eviction notices even after being granted forest rights titles. The problems tribal communities face today demand attention. Ending the injustices they continue to face requires action on the ground that serves their interests. (IPA Service)
