By Mahesh Rathi
When rapists and murderers begin to be glorified and released, understand that the moral decline of society is taking place.
The Supreme Court’s decision in the Bilkis Bano gang rape and massacre case to suspend the life imprisonment sentences of two convicts and grant them bail once again raises serious questions about the country’s judicial system and the moral conscience of society. Bilkis Bano has expressed deep disappointment, grief and anguish over this decision. Many citizens, women’s organisations and human rights activists across the country have also expressed their displeasure over it.
This case is not merely about the bail granted to two convicts. It is a question of the political and social environment in which attempts are being made to gradually normalise even heinous crimes such as rape, murder and communal massacres. The question is: Can our sensitivities towards such brutality die to such an extent in any civilised society that, with the passage of time, the gravity of the crime and the suffering of the victim themselves become secondary?
During the communal violence in Gujarat in 2002, 21-year-old Bilkis Bano, who was five months pregnant, was gang-raped. Seven members of her family, including her three-year-old daughter, were brutally murdered. This brutality against a pregnant woman and the massacre of her family before her eyes constitute the most shameful and darkest chapter in the history of independent India. No victim can ever fully recover from such a tragedy throughout her life. For her, justice does not merely mean punishing the guilty; it also means the assurance that society and the state will never consider the crime committed against her to be normal.
The Supreme Court, while hearing the appeals of Bipinchandra Joshi and Pradeep Modhiya on 28 October 2026, suspended their sentences and granted them bail. The court considered certain grounds, including their having spent more than 17 years in prison and the serious physical disability of one of the convicts. It is true that this is not an acquittal, but the convicts have certainly received relief.
However, this decision and the entire legal process raise several serious questions. How important are the suffering and security of the woman whose life has been changed forever by this heinous crime in the judicial process? Can justice remain limited only to the rights of the convicts and legal relief for them? The dignity, security and right of the victim to obtain justice are also fundamental responsibilities of the judicial system.
The earlier sequence of events in this case is no less serious. Questions were raised about the initial investigation by the local police. The Supreme Court had to hand over the investigation to the CBI, and to ensure a fair trial, the case had to be transferred from Gujarat to Maharashtra. In 2008, a special court in Mumbai sentenced 11 persons to life imprisonment, and in May 2017, the Bombay High Court upheld their convictions.
Despite this, on 15 August 2022, the Gujarat government prematurely released all these 11 convicts. Even more shameful was the fact that they were welcomed upon coming out of prison, sweets were distributed and they were publicly felicitated. What kind of social and political mentality did this demonstrate? Can presenting those convicted of gang rape and murder as heroes be the identity of any civilised society?
On 8 January 2024, the Supreme Court quashed the release orders of the Gujarat government. The court made it clear that the Gujarat government was not the competent government to grant remission of sentences in this case and that it had taken the decision by exceeding its jurisdiction. This judgment was a serious judicial observation on the role of the state government.
The most dangerous aspect of this entire episode is the politics of hatred that creates the habit of viewing human beings on the basis of their religious identity. In this, greater importance is given to the communal identity of the criminal and the victim than to the gravity of the crime. If a person from one’s own community commits a crime, arguments are fabricated in his defence, political protection is provided to him and sometimes he is even glorified. If a person from another community becomes a victim, even his suffering is viewed with suspicion and hatred. This is the real face of communal fascism.
The objective of fascism is not limited merely to acquiring political power; it is also to bring the moral conscience and human sensitivities of society under its control. It divides people to such an extent that even human suffering begins to be viewed through the lens of religious identity. The identity of a rapist and murderer becomes greater than his crime, and the identity of the victim is made greater than her human rights. The welcome extended to the convicts in the Bilkis Bano case was an example of this distorted mentality.
The greatest concern is that the politics of hatred gradually begins to influence the functioning of state institutions and social behaviour as well. Questions begin to arise about the impartiality of the police, administration, prosecution and government. The sequence of events in the Bilkis Bano case, from the initial police action to the premature release of the convicts, raises precisely this question of institutional accountability.
When governments begin to seek political convenience in granting relief to those convicted of heinous crimes, when the administration appears more sensitive towards the interests of those in power than towards the security and justice of the victim, and when a section of society felicitates criminals, the matter no longer remains merely a law-and-order problem. It is an indication of the erosion of democratic and constitutional values.
After the Second World War, the principle of holding Nazi criminals accountable in the Nuremberg trials was based on the understanding that crimes against humanity cannot be accepted as ordinary political events. The process of truth and justice after the end of apartheid in South Africa also established that society can move forward only by confronting the crimes of its past, not by forgetting them.
Today, the danger is not merely that some people spread hatred. The real danger is that hatred is gradually gaining social acceptance. First, a crime takes place; then arguments are presented in its defence; then criminals are glorified; and ultimately, the entire society begins to consider it normal. Even state institutions begin to lose their sensitivity and accountability under the pressure of this normalisation.
Therefore, critically examining the Supreme Court’s decision in the Bilkis Bano case is not an insult to the judiciary but a democratic right. The decisions of the judiciary are also subjects of public debate and constitutional scrutiny. Justice does not merely mean completing the legal process; it also means maintaining society’s faith in justice.
Getting justice for Bilkis Bano is not a question concerning only one woman or one community. It is a question of protecting the India envisioned by the Constitution, where the life, dignity and rights of every citizen are equally valuable. It is a country where rapists and murderers are not felicitated, but where there is social resistance against their crimes.
It must be remembered that the moral decline of a society does not begin on the day criminals commit heinous crimes; it begins on the day society starts justifying their crimes. The struggle against the politics of hatred is therefore not merely a struggle against communalism, but a struggle to save humanity, democracy and civilisation. (IPA Service)
