Former air force vice-chief disputes Rafale inventory count

IPA Staff
6 Min Read
Former Air Force vice-chief Air Marshal Narmdeshwar Tiwari has rejected a British aviation directory’s assessment that India operates only 32 Rafale fighters, disputing figures that have renewed arguments over aircraft losses during last year’s conflict with Pakistan.

Tiwari, who was vice-chief during Operation Sindoor in May 2025, described the assessment as “patently false” and urged FlightGlobal to reconsider the information used to compile its annual World Air Forces directory. India purchased 36 Rafales from France, while the publication’s 2027 edition lists 32 as active.

The discrepancy has prompted objections from serving Air Force sources, who maintain that the published figure is wrong and that the service did not supply its fleet data to the publication. Neither FlightGlobal’s figures nor the objections provide a publicly verified, aircraft-by-aircraft accounting of the fleet’s present operational status. The competing assessments leave unresolved whether the difference concerns aircraft availability, permanent losses or the methodology used to categorise individual jets.

“FlightGlobal should re-evaluate their sources,” Tiwari wrote on X on Thursday. He said sources associated with earlier claims had identified individual Rafales as destroyed, although aircraft bearing those identifiers subsequently participated in flying exercises, including international engagements.

Tiwari also questioned previous assertions that Squadron Leader Shivangi Singh had been captured by Pakistan during the hostilities. Singh subsequently appeared publicly alongside President Droupadi Murmu at Ambala airbase, contradicting the prisoner-of-war allegation.

The annual directory, prepared using aviation data provider Cirium’s military fleet information, gives no explanation for the latest reduction. It does not identify the four aircraft missing from the total acquired or establish whether any discrepancy arises from combat losses, maintenance, classification differences or incomplete records.

The previous edition, issued in November 2025, listed 35 Rafales as active. Its latest count therefore represents a reduction of three against that estimate, although the published total is four below the 36 aircraft delivered under India’s original procurement agreement.

Defence officials have challenged the provenance of the data, stressing that it was not provided by the Ministry of Defence. Their objections underline the distinction between externally compiled fleet estimates and information confirmed by the military operator, which has not published a detailed inventory resolving the discrepancy.

Officials have also cited an Air Force tender issued in June 2026 seeking a temporary maintenance and technical support arrangement covering all 36 Rafale aircraft. The procurement document provides evidence that support planning continued on the basis of the full original fleet, although a maintenance tender does not independently establish that every aircraft was combat-ready at a particular time.

The dispute has revived competing accounts of the aerial fighting during Operation Sindoor, launched on 7 May 2025 following the killing of 26 people in an attack at Pahalgam. Pakistan claimed to have shot down several aircraft, including Rafales, during the subsequent clashes.

India’s military acknowledged aircraft losses during the fighting but did not publicly specify their number and types. It disputed Pakistan’s higher claims about the scale of the losses. Consequently, assertions that the directory verifies four Rafales were destroyed go beyond what its published figures establish.

The Rafale’s manufacturer, Dassault Aviation, has also challenged Pakistani assertions. Chief executive Éric Trappier described claims about Rafale shootdowns as inaccurate in June 2025 while indicating that authorities in India had not provided the company with details of any such losses.

FlightGlobal’s inventory is designed to provide a comparative account of military aviation holdings worldwide. Its use of third-party information means the published category of active aircraft should not automatically be equated with a government-certified count of aircraft available for immediate operations.

Cirium draws on aircraft identification information, public sightings, flight records and aviation-related reporting to maintain fleet datasets. Such methods can help track individual airframes but may not fully capture the status of military aircraft whose movements and maintenance information are not routinely disclosed.

The controversy comes as India pursues plans to acquire additional Rafale fighters, separate from the 36 aircraft already delivered to the Air Force. The service’s original fleet comprises single-seat and twin-seat variants produced by Dassault Aviation under the agreement signed with France in 2016.

The latest directory places the Rafale DH/EH model under the Air Force entry for India, using its active-aircraft column to show 32. The directory’s published table does not accompany that figure with individual aircraft serial numbers or explanations for changes from the preceding edition.

TAGGED:
Share This Article