By Nilotpal Basu
For the last one and a half years, the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has stayed in the headlines. To start with, it was confined to independent media, through YouTubers and digital portals. But the process has been so controversial and, at times, so outrageous that the subject has now gatecrashed into the mainstream media space as well. Of course, the issue has also assumed such prominence because of the Opposition’s initiative to sustain public focus and keep the subject in the limelight.
This was only to be expected, because it involves the very nature of electoral democracy. The legitimacy of an elected government depends on the transparency and fairness of the conduct of the electoral process. There can be no two opinions that this fundamentally requires a level playing field, which the Election Commission is tasked with ensuring. It is from this standpoint that the current ECI has come under such intense scrutiny.
However, what needs to be emphasised is the importance of the very notion of citizenship, which is the core question that needs to be properly understood and assimilated. As testimony to the controversial nature of the SIR, right from its initial phase in Bihar, matters were referred to the judiciary, particularly the apex court. What else could have been expected? The Constitution itself unambiguously states that the fairness of the electoral process depends on the independent functioning of the ECI, and therefore makes it an independent constitutional entity, insulating it from extraneous political pressures, particularly from the ruling party.
To ensure this, the Constitution was explicit in Article 326 that the election would have to be truly universal franchise driven, with the citizen at its heart. The Constitution presumed the citizenship of a voter on the basis of self-declaration. The ECI, however, was given the responsibility of verifying that declaration. Subsequent laws and rules established a statutory procedure for conducting such verification, as and when necessary. But the fine print was not implicit. The ECI did not have the right to determine the citizenship of a voter. Specific forms were provided for under those provisions, which could be filed if other citizens in the vicinity doubted the identity of that voter.
Even though the apex court did not conclusively settle several of the legal controversies, the Supreme Court has emphatically pointed out that the appearance or non-appearance of a voter’s name in the electoral roll cannot be held as a final verdict on his or her citizenship.
It is also very clear that the use of Form 7, and its recognition and validation by the ECI, has been one of the most controversial aspects of the overall debate on SIR. The misuse of Form 7 for deletions, its submission in bulk by the BJP and its booth-level agents, and even by the ECI itself (in West Bengal), are now on record through the ECI’s own affidavit before the apex court.
The fact of the matter is that, although large numbers of voters have suffered mass disenfranchisement, the unstated yet underlying narrative is that those whose names are deleted are presumed to be non-citizens. Intimately linked to this narrative is the BJP-RSS campaign in the backdrop, particularly in Assam and Bengal, alleging that infiltrators from Bangladesh have swamped the electoral rolls and corrupted the voters’ list. This narrative was officially legitimised by the ECI in its first notification on June 24, 2025. Even though the ECI is not empowered to determine citizenship, it has presumptively asserted this power as the main justification for the disenfranchisement exercise.
Is this accidental? The answer is in the negative. Amit Shah’s loud assertion was that the voter list revision would aim to ‘detect, delete, deport’ the ‘infiltrators who have vitiated the rolls’. The ECI, however, could not produce a shred of evidence to prove that such a case had been made out in its formal decision-making process. Despite the huge disenfranchisement, to the tune of 13.5 crore voters, the number of identified infiltrators is microscopically insignificant. Even among this small number, most were from Nepal. Some State Chief Electoral Officers have pointed out that this was not a question that had been asked.
Therefore, it is clear that the whole issue of infiltrators was a bogey to facilitate the bringing in of citizenship to the fore and attribute it with a big question mark. Meanwhile, BJP-led state governments, and now even the Panchayati Raj Ministry of the Central Government, have announced that it is not Aadhaar but EPIC and biometrics that will be the prescribed as the basis for access to government schemes and funds, despite the Supreme Court’s express opinion to the contrary.
With this subterfuge to put the citizenship question in doubt, we cannot but look back at the historical position of the Hindutva forces on the question of citizenship. It was Savarkar, in his pamphlet ‘Who Is a Hindu’ posited that those for whom India is both the ‘pitr bhumi’ and ‘punya bhumi’ were to be regarded as citizens. That is how religious identity was sought to be pushed as the basis for nationhood and citizenship covertly. Of course, Golwalkar further reinforced this in more explicit terms in his ‘We or Our Nationhood Defined’.
But for almost seven decades, the question of citizenship had remained buried before being vigorously revived during the Ram Janmabhoomi campaign. But strictly speaking, Savarkar’s vision differs from the current clamour. As a subtle difference, the present drive for a Hindu Rashtra is laced with a more overt assertion of Brahminical religiosity. Either way, the aim is to deny the democratic, secular basis of the Republic by extraneously importing the religious identity question to define nationhood and citizenship. Therefore, the current assault goes beyond the voting right and strikes at the heart of citizenship and nationhood. Without comprehending these wider ramifications, the severity of the current challenge cannot be faced. (IPA Service)
