The incident occurred as representatives of the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena ripped pages from Belonging: A Journey of Love, accusing the Congress leader of insulting Hindutva ideologue V D Savarkar. Video footage showed Shaina tearing part of a photograph depicting Thackeray striking an effigy of former Union minister Mani Shankar Aiyar.
Shaina disputed allegations that she had damaged Thackeray’s image, insisting that she had targeted the depiction of Aiyar. Her explanation failed to prevent protests by the rival Shiv Sena (UBT), whose representatives accused the Shinde faction of disrespecting the founder whose legacy both parties claim.
The controversy reached the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation, where corporators from Shiv Sena (UBT) and the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena walked out of a general body meeting. Opposition representatives also protested at the civic headquarters, demanding action against Shaina.
Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Kishori Pednekar called for her resignation, while party MP Sanjay Raut accused the Shinde group of betraying its professed loyalty to Bal Thackeray. Congress leaders joined the criticism, arguing that tearing books was an unacceptable response to political disagreement.
Shaina rejected the accusation in a statement posted on X. “Show me where I have torn or disrespected Hindu Hriday Samrat Balasaheb Thackeray’s photograph,” she said, warning that she would take legal action against people spreading what she described as defamatory claims.
Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde defended his colleague, saying she had shown him what she tore and that nobody in his party would insult Bal Thackeray. His intervention followed demands from opposition leaders that the party explain the incident.
The press conference had been intended to challenge Gandhi’s account of Savarkar and put pressure on Uddhav Thackeray, whose Shiv Sena (UBT) is allied with the Congress. The Shinde faction questioned how Uddhav could accept a copy of the memoir while maintaining his party’s longstanding regard for Savarkar.
Six spokespersons participated in the demonstration: Shaina, Sanjay Nirupam, Sheetal Mhatre, Sanjana Ghadi, Anand Dubey and Sushiben Shah. They displayed photographs contrasting Bal Thackeray’s opposition to Aiyar with Uddhav Thackeray’s acceptance of Gandhi’s book before tearing printed material.
One photograph recalled a 2004 protest during which Bal Thackeray struck an effigy of Aiyar with footwear over remarks concerning Savarkar. The sheet containing that photograph was caught up in Wednesday’s demonstration, and a colleague alerted Shaina as she tore it. She then set the damaged sheet aside.
Nirupam accused Gandhi of showing hostility towards Savarkar and called for the memoir to be banned. Other spokespersons demanded that publisher HarperCollins remove passages on pages 201 and 443, which they said offended supporters of the freedom fighter.
Gandhi’s memoir discusses Savarkar’s petitions for clemency to British colonial authorities and makes allegations about members of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh cooperating with the colonial administration. The Shiv Sena rejects her portrayal, describing it as an attack on Savarkar and Maharashtra’s political heritage.
Congress spokesperson Atul Londhe defended Gandhi’s account and said Savarkar’s mercy petitions were a matter of historical record. Congress leader Balasaheb Thorat argued that disagreement with a published work should be expressed through debate rather than destruction of its pages.
Congress leader Vijay Wadettiwar similarly criticised the demonstration, saying objections to a book could be presented democratically or answered through another publication. Nana Patole demanded police action against those involved in tearing the material, while Mumbai Congress leader Varsha Gaikwad accused the protesters of insulting Thackeray’s memory.
Shinde faction spokesperson Shital Mhatre challenged Uddhav Thackeray to clarify whether he accepted Gandhi’s comments about Savarkar. The faction also invoked his earlier support for honouring Savarkar with the Bharat Ratna, seeking to highlight differences between its rival’s historical positions and its present alliance with Congress.
The political dispute also drew a response from BJP leader Pravin Darekar, who said protesters should exercise greater care and apologise if they had accidentally damaged Thackeray’s photograph. His comments contrasted with the opposition’s demands for formal disciplinary action against Shaina.
The confrontation took place one day after the anniversary of Bal Thackeray’s death, a timing opposition leaders cited while criticising the protest. Separately, Shiv Sena (UBT) workers demonstrated outside the Shinde faction’s Balasaheb Bhavan office in Mumbai.
