Supreme Court summons responses on judicial appointment rules

IPA Staff
6 Min Read
The Supreme Court has sought responses from the Centre and its Secretary General to a petition demanding completion of long-pending rules governing appointments to the higher judiciary.

A bench of Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale issued notices on Wednesday, November 18, on a public interest petition filed by Lok Prahari, a Lucknow-based non-governmental organisation. The petition seeks finalisation of the revised Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) and greater public access to decisions taken by judicial Collegiums.

The organisation says the revision has remained unfinished for almost 11 years despite directions issued by a Constitution Bench in December 2015. It has asked the court to require the Union Ministry of Law and Justice to finalise the document within one month, following consultation with the Chief Justice of India.

The petition also seeks disclosure under the Right to Information Act of minutes relating to the selection of judges by the Supreme Court and High Court Collegiums. It argues that making the decision-making process accessible would improve transparency and accountability in appointments to constitutional courts.

The bench permitted Lok Prahari to submit an amended petition. Issuing notice does not amount to accepting the organisation’s allegations or granting its requests. The government and the Supreme Court’s administrative establishment have been asked to respond before the matter proceeds further.

During the hearing, Justice Sundresh raised the question of whether he should hear the case because he is a member of the Supreme Court Collegium. Senior advocate Sanjay Hegde, appearing for Lok Prahari, said he had no objection to the judge hearing the matter. The bench then proceeded to issue notice.

The hearing followed an earlier listing on November 2, when Justice PS Narasimha withdrew from the matter because he had appeared as an additional solicitor general in litigation concerning the judicial appointments procedure. The case was subsequently placed before a different bench.

The MoP sets out the administrative process for recommending, scrutinising and processing appointments and transfers involving judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts. The existing framework operates alongside the Collegium system, under which senior judges recommend candidates for appointment to the constitutional courts.

The dispute over revisions dates to the Supreme Court’s October 2015 ruling striking down the National Judicial Appointments Commission, which Parliament had established to replace the Collegium. While retaining the judicial appointments system, the court acknowledged calls to improve its functioning, including its transparency and the criteria used in selecting judges.

On December 16, 2015, a Constitution Bench directed that the MoP be supplemented through a process involving the government and the Chief Justice of India, acting on the collective view of the four senior-most Supreme Court judges. The proposed revision has not been formally concluded amid differences between the executive and judiciary.

Lok Prahari contends that the prolonged delay has left unresolved deficiencies in the selection process. Its petition describes a lack of transparency and objectivity as harmful to the quality of judicial appointments and, consequently, to litigants seeking justice. Those assertions remain the petitioner’s case, not findings made by the bench hearing the matter.

The organisation has asked that recommendations for judicial appointments reflect the unanimous view of the Collegium and take account of standards it considers necessary for impartial and independent judging. Its demands would require consideration of how existing appointment procedures operate and what information may lawfully be made public.

The petition also refers to efforts to obtain information about the status of the revised document. Lok Prahari says representations submitted to the Law Ministry in December 2015 were not acknowledged and that subsequent requests under the transparency law failed to provide satisfactory details of progress.

The court has not fixed a deadline for completing the revision at this stage. Nor has it directed disclosure of Collegium records. Both questions remain among the substantive issues raised by the petition for consideration after replies.

A further point raised in the petition concerns access to records of Collegium deliberations, rather than merely the recommendations eventually announced. The request therefore goes beyond completing an administrative document and seeks more extensive disclosure of how individual candidates are considered.

Lok Prahari’s general secretary SN Shukla has pursued the issue through the organisation, while advocate Shashank Singh filed the petition. The bench’s order allows changes to the pleadings before the respondents present their positions on the issues raised.

TAGGED:
Share This Article