The US District Court for the Southern District of New York instructed its clerk to send documents by international mail or courier to three district courts, seeking their assistance in serving the two defendants. The order concerns the method of delivering legal papers, not a determination of the allegations.
Patiala House District Court has been identified for documents concerning Doval, while courts at Dwarka and Tis Hazari have been identified for Goel. The documents are intended for courts with jurisdiction over addresses where the defendants are believed to reside.
Sources familiar with the matter characterised the summons as non-binding and described the exercise as procedural. That assessment does not itself settle whether service would be recognised under applicable law. There has been no finding of liability against either official in the civil proceedings.
The transmission directive follows a November 9 ruling by District Judge Katherine Polk Failla authorising Pannun to attempt service through the Delhi courts. The judge accepted the proposed route after earlier attempts using the central authority under the Hague Service Convention were rejected.
The November 9 order required Pannun to submit a proposed package of documents by November 30, including the summons, supporting legal provisions, evidence of rejected service requests and a formal request for assistance. The court said its clerk would forward the materials after judicial approval.
The court’s subsequent direction identifies the receiving courts and specifies mail or courier as the means of transmission. Whether the papers have been delivered to the defendants, or whether the Delhi courts have acted on the request, has not been established.
The case arises from Pannun’s allegations of a conspiracy to assassinate him in New York. His September 2024 lawsuit names the government of India, Doval, Goel, Vikram Yadav, Nikhil Gupta and unidentified defendants. These are civil allegations contested by New Delhi, not findings made by the court.
The Ministry of External Affairs has dismissed the accusations as fabricated and malicious. Spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said on November 11 that official communications concerning service of judicial documents must be channelled through the Ministry of Law and Justice, the designated authority for such matters.
The procedural disagreement centres on the Hague Convention, an international agreement governing service of civil and commercial judicial documents abroad. The New York court concluded that Article 19 permits methods allowed by the domestic law of the receiving country, notwithstanding the failure of Pannun’s earlier attempts through the central authority.
Judge Failla considered Section 29 of India’s Code of Civil Procedure, a 2009 government notification applying its provisions to courts in countries party to the convention, and rules allowing summons to be transmitted between courts. She found those provisions sufficient to authorise an attempt through the identified Delhi courts.
The ruling did not require the Delhi judiciary to decide the allegations. Nor did it establish that transmission to a court automatically amounts to completed service on an individual defendant. Further steps under the receiving jurisdiction’s procedures remain distinct from the US court’s authorisation.
The US State Department had transmitted papers concerning the lawsuit to the embassy of India in Washington. It informed the New York court that it took no position on Pannun’s proposal to use the Delhi judiciary for service. The diplomatic transmission was not an endorsement of his claims.
Earlier, the judge rejected alternative proposals involving service by email, publication or diplomatic channels, citing restrictions under the convention and governing US law. The court’s April ruling instead invited further submissions addressing the possibility of using courts in India.
The lawsuit is separate from federal criminal proceedings in the United States concerning an alleged murder-for-hire plot targeting Pannun. Allegations in the criminal case do not establish responsibility for any defendant in the civil case, which remains subject to its own procedural and evidentiary requirements.
The November 9 order also specified that Pannun’s proposed package should include a record of the unsuccessful Hague Convention requests and a request that receiving courts provide documentation of any service carried out. Such records would allow the New York court to assess what procedural steps had occurred.
