• Latest
  • Trending
CJI Ranjan Gogoi’s Tryst With History

CJI Ranjan Gogoi’s Tryst With History

October 21, 2019

BJP Led By Narendra Modi Battles Hard In State Polls

April 3, 2021

India’s ‘World’s Pharmacy’ Tag Is Facing A Threat

April 3, 2021
ADVERTISEMENT

A Slew Of Setbacks For The Congress Leader Chennithala On Poll-Eve

April 3, 2021

India Must Avoid Any Panic Reaction Amidst The Second Covid-19 Wave

April 3, 2021

Connectivity Has Emerged As A Focus Area Of India And Bangladesh

April 3, 2021

BJP Led NDA Facing Toughest Test In Third Phase Of Assam Polls On April 6

April 3, 2021

Modi-Shah’s Double Standards On CAA May Affect BJP In Assam

April 3, 2021

Bhupesh Baghel Emerges As Prominent Organiser Within Congress

April 3, 2021

Mamata’s Opposition Unity Call Has Big Relevance For 2024 Lok Sabha Polls

April 1, 2021

Amit Shah Is Dream Merchant For Sonar Bangla Without Knowing Its Origin

April 1, 2021

After Freedom House, V-Dem, The Turn Of The US State Department

April 1, 2021

How Long This Jobless Economic Planning Will Continue In India?

April 1, 2021
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Setup menu at Appearance » Menus and assign menu to Top Bar Navigation
Saturday, April 3, 2021
No Result
View All Result
IPA Newspack
  • Setup menu at Appearance » Menus and assign menu to Main Navigation
  • Setup menu at Appearance » Menus and assign menu to Main Navigation
No Result
View All Result
IPA Newspack
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT

CJI Ranjan Gogoi’s Tryst With History

IPA Staff by IPA Staff
October 21, 2019
in Uncategorized
3 min read
0
CJI Ranjan Gogoi’s Tryst With History
ADVERTISEMENT

By K Raveendran

 

RelatedArticles

BJP Led By Narendra Modi Battles Hard In State Polls

India’s ‘World’s Pharmacy’ Tag Is Facing A Threat

A Slew Of Setbacks For The Congress Leader Chennithala On Poll-Eve

If Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi manages to produce a verdict on the vexed Ayodhya land dispute before he retires next month, which he seems to be poised to do in all likelihood, his name will be etched in golden letters in the annals of Indian history.

 

The Chief Justice has made it abundantly clear that he means business, when on the last day of hearing  he refused to entertain new interventions, saying ‘enough is enough’. As the deadline drew nearer, there were multiple attempts to frustrate Justice Gogoi’s resolve and the day was marked by total confusion, with conflicting reports emanating from different sources about different options being tossed up for the consideration of the court.

 

ADVERTISEMENT

One of these suggested that the Sunni Waqf Board, one of the main parties to the dispute, has decided to withdraw its suit as its chairman has told the Ayodhya mediation panel that they are ready to give up their claim on their land, but subject to certain conditions. There is no confirmation yet on the issue, but even if it is true, it should not affect the proceedings in the court as the Waqf Board is only one of the several litigants.

 

If one goes by the logistics of the case so far, the CJI’s target would sound intimidating. But the issue is not of time alone. If the case has lingered on for 70 years, it is not because there wasn’t enough time to consider all aspects of the dispute, but rather the approach of the court itself and that of the contending parties. It is this approach that Justice Gogoi is seeking to change.

 

Throughout the history of the litigation, the judicial process has been guided by convenience, rather than the resolve to find a solution, which saw the case being tossed back and forth. With so many interests at work, the courts could not take a position on the merit of the case alone, although that itself was anything but simple and straightforward. There were layers of religious, communal and political intricacies that made an impassioned approach impossible.

 

The first big change occurred during former CJI Dipak Misra’s time, when the constitutional bench led by him decided to strip the case down to a dispute on the title deed. Postulating a clinical approach, the then CJI made it clear that he would not be swayed by the history of religious conflict and the communal tensions associated with the site and warded off third party interventions, which would have further complicated the issue.

 

What perhaps had even a greater bearing on the future of the case was the judgment that a mosque was not integral to the Muslim way of worship, which removed a vital angle from the dispute and it became easier to narrow the consideration to the ownership of the land and the  claim of the devotees of Ram. Pleas for referring the decision to review by a five-member constitutional bench were met with a firm ‘no’.

 

Justice Misra’s bench had briefly shown the readiness to fast track a decision, but the approaching elections and the retirement of the CJI put paid to all hopes of a breakthrough, especially since the Hindutva forces wanted to force a decision in time for the elections while the Opposition resisted with all its might.

 

Now it is Justice Gogoi’s moment for a tryst with history and he seems to be eminently set up for such a glory. Despite the fiasco of the court-appointed mediation panel, which was destined to fail even before it was formally constituted due to inherent contradictions, leading to its virtual disbanding, the straws in the wind indicated a sense of realism dawning on the Muslim parties, particularly the Shia groups, who have increasingly been adopting a reconciliatory stance.

 

After a hiatus, now the panel has resumed work and its chief, former Supreme Court judge F M I Kalifulla is still optimistic of mediating an agreed settlement among the parties. At one stage, one of the Muslim parties had floated the idea of both the Ram Temple and the Babri Masjid being constructed through a collaborative effort, the latter at an alternative site.

 

For the Hindus, Ram’s birth place is unquestionably non-negotiable and therefore Ram Mandir is a life and death issue. The Babri Masjid, although shorn off its religious significance in view of the Supreme Court decision, is the most widely recognised symbol of secularism in the country.

 

The fight is, therefore, between faith and symbolism. With secularism no longer being the flavour of the season, the dice is loaded in favour of faith. But more importantly, a reconciliation appears to be within the realm of possibilities.

 

ADVERTISEMENT

A Supreme Court order, with or without contributions from the mediation panel, will also avert a situation that could encourage militant Hindutva elements to embark on any misadventure similar to the 1992 episode, which had led to irreparable damage to the fabric of national unity.  No saner elements would ever want a re-enactment of the episode, which is another reason why anybody would want to wish Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi success. (IPA Service)

 

 

 

ADVERTISEMENT

 

 

ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

Economic Slowdown Turning Into A Real Crisis

Next Post

Democratic Hopefuls Unite On Impeachment, Spar On Medicare-For-All

IPA Staff

IPA Staff

Related Posts

IPA Service

BJP Led By Narendra Modi Battles Hard In State Polls

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
IPA Service

India’s ‘World’s Pharmacy’ Tag Is Facing A Threat

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
IPA Service

A Slew Of Setbacks For The Congress Leader Chennithala On Poll-Eve

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
IPA Service

India Must Avoid Any Panic Reaction Amidst The Second Covid-19 Wave

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
IPA Service

Connectivity Has Emerged As A Focus Area Of India And Bangladesh

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
IPA Service

BJP Led NDA Facing Toughest Test In Third Phase Of Assam Polls On April 6

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
Load More
Next Post
Green New Deal For Climate Change Is Need Of The Hour

Democratic Hopefuls Unite On Impeachment, Spar On Medicare-For-All

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

ADVERTISEMENT

Recommended

Asuras And Atheists In God’s Own Country

2 years ago

Shifting Focus: Pharma MNCs Now Look To Tie-Ups With Indian Firms

9 years ago
Load More
ADVERTISEMENT

Contact

India Press Agency D-34, Basement, Gulmohar Park, Delhi - 110049 Gautam Nagar, New Delhi
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

About Us

IPA Newspack

IPA Intelligence Unit is a specialist service of India Press Agency (IPA), one of the oldest news agencies of India.

  • Setup menu at Appearance » Menus and assign menu to Footer Navigation

© 2020 India Press Agency - Latest Breaking news and Opinion IPA Media Group | Arabian Post

No Result
View All Result

© 2020 India Press Agency - Latest Breaking news and Opinion IPA Media Group | Arabian Post

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In