• Latest
  • Trending

Ensuring Excellence In Research In India

April 23, 2012

BJP Led By Narendra Modi Battles Hard In State Polls

April 3, 2021

India’s ‘World’s Pharmacy’ Tag Is Facing A Threat

April 3, 2021
ADVERTISEMENT

A Slew Of Setbacks For The Congress Leader Chennithala On Poll-Eve

April 3, 2021

India Must Avoid Any Panic Reaction Amidst The Second Covid-19 Wave

April 3, 2021

Connectivity Has Emerged As A Focus Area Of India And Bangladesh

April 3, 2021

BJP Led NDA Facing Toughest Test In Third Phase Of Assam Polls On April 6

April 3, 2021

Modi-Shah’s Double Standards On CAA May Affect BJP In Assam

April 3, 2021

Bhupesh Baghel Emerges As Prominent Organiser Within Congress

April 3, 2021

Mamata’s Opposition Unity Call Has Big Relevance For 2024 Lok Sabha Polls

April 1, 2021

Amit Shah Is Dream Merchant For Sonar Bangla Without Knowing Its Origin

April 1, 2021

After Freedom House, V-Dem, The Turn Of The US State Department

April 1, 2021

How Long This Jobless Economic Planning Will Continue In India?

April 1, 2021
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Setup menu at Appearance » Menus and assign menu to Top Bar Navigation
Saturday, April 3, 2021
No Result
View All Result
IPA Newspack
  • Setup menu at Appearance » Menus and assign menu to Main Navigation
  • Setup menu at Appearance » Menus and assign menu to Main Navigation
No Result
View All Result
IPA Newspack
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT

Ensuring Excellence In Research In India

IPA Staff by IPA Staff
April 23, 2012
in Uncategorized
4 min read
0
ADVERTISEMENT

RelatedArticles

BJP Led By Narendra Modi Battles Hard In State Polls

India’s ‘World’s Pharmacy’ Tag Is Facing A Threat

A Slew Of Setbacks For The Congress Leader Chennithala On Poll-Eve

By Garga Chatterjee

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

For academic discourse, two things that are of utmost importance are quality and iconoclasm. Both are easier stated than implemented. We need iconoclasm in the world of knowledge to both expand and question our conceptions of the world. Ideas, especially those on which the reputation of stalwart academicians and their ‘intellectual’ children depend, those which conform to ideologies of the state, are especially hard to challenge and discredit. It is important to foster iconoclasm so that knowledge does not become a tool in the sustenance of the powerful.
Those who claim to want to change this equation between ideas and power, more than often recreate stifling power hegemonies themselves, if they happen to capture some part of the academic sphere themselves. All through the euphoric seventies and the pre-doomsday eighties, the way Marxist   academics in India coerced budding students into their ideological predilections, through thinly veiled carrots and sticks, peppering departments all over the country with their ideological kith and kin, should serve as a grim reminder of what intellectual fascism can be unleashed in the name of fighting conformity and hegemony.
The veritable boom in the number of thesis and research papers coming out of Jawaharlal Nehru University, Calcutta University and Jadavpur University during that period, that employed ‘Marxian analysis’ is a sad testament to this. Ideological limitations, the need to reward loyalties and conformity, combined with an intricate system of informal mutual back-scratching helped permeate close-mindedness in academia, right upto departments in small colleges.
Atop this hierarchy sat the nomenklatura – now, not so much out of favour as it touts to be, more out of fashion than it wants to be. The pariah status that an academic of the class of Ashis Nandy was accorded is a telling reminder how erstwhile champions of things heterodox can quickly transform themselves into defenders of status-quo, discouraging multiple heterodoxies. Iconoclasm, while being aimed at existing hegemons, cannot be a pretext for spreading petty mediocrity, so as to entrench vested interests, making their uprooting that much harder.
West Bengalis still reeling from this phenomenon. It is not clear yet whether the ‘greenwashed’ future will be any different. Though employed here for the purposes of illustration, encouraging nepotism, spreading mediocrity, propagating hegemonies, creating a nomenklatura based on in-group loyalties, shrillness and service to power, is by no means an exclusively ‘red’ disease.
An ecology where reasoned iconoclasm reigns supreme needs, among other things, a democratic setup and the student-professor relationship that is like that one between peers. It needs to be a space where deference to truth and evidence comes foremost, where plagiarism is dealt with ruthlessly, where students and research scholars who oppose the academic ideas of their mentors cannot be threatened with ‘dire consequences’, where individual brilliance of a student that surpasses that of the professor causes celebration rather than anxiety, where ‘stalwart academics’ can be heckled by sound logic and shown their place if need be. Finally, it needs to be place where that great unmentionable called quality reigns supreme. The last point is especially important for research, as many of the researchers will come to populate the teaching departments of India.
One way by which hegemonies are perpetuated in academia in India, are by faculty appointments on the basis considerations other than academic quality. In a scenario so rife with nepotism and favouritism based on academic lineage, political inclination and other vested interests, setting an objective quality bar hits right at the heart of these informal structures of patronage. Though by no means perfect, one useful index of academic quality is impact factor or H-index. Academic research, in the natural and social sciences, is mainly published in specialized journals. Impact factor  or H-index are various measures of citation and quality of journal where one published their work, indicative of how many other people deem your research important or relevant enough to refer to it in their own work published in an indexed journal. There are many indexed journals in India too. While not prostrating totally at the altar of impact factor, a deference to that deity might serve well to separate the wheat from the chaff generated by prejudiced, ideological and nepotistic calls that faculty recruitment committees often make, using the cover of subjective assessment.
There have been for sometime currents within the world of science that seek to remove the commercial barrier to knowledge access. Open-access journals which can be read freely all over the world are part of this. The charge that peer-reviews may be prejudiced against those espousing uncomfortable and heterodox ideas is now being countered with innovations in the methods of review, open review and even scope for open-debate during the review process. Journals with open access and newer forms of review are being cited highly and many have established themselves repute in a very short time. It is this process of open-access and open review to level the international playing field in knowledge production that India can ride high on, rather than viewing the demand for quality as a conspiracy.
Of course, all that there is or should be, has a context. It exists in the backdrop of India’s stark social inequity, a global order that seeks to promote and reward certain voices and stifle others, an increasing commercialisation and corporatisation of the vehicles of public discourse, a culture that equates research utility with the private profits that it can generate. India needs vigorous affirmative action and democratization of academic and institutional cultures. The institutions need quality and autonomy and the imagination to wed the two. (IPA Service)
Dr Garga Chatterjee, a doctorate from Harvard University, is presently a post-doctorate scholar at MIT, USA.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

Petroleum Ministry To Improve Climate For Oil, Gas Investments

Next Post

Children Rally Against Early Marriage

IPA Staff

IPA Staff

Related Posts

IPA Service

BJP Led By Narendra Modi Battles Hard In State Polls

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
IPA Service

India’s ‘World’s Pharmacy’ Tag Is Facing A Threat

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
IPA Service

A Slew Of Setbacks For The Congress Leader Chennithala On Poll-Eve

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
IPA Service

India Must Avoid Any Panic Reaction Amidst The Second Covid-19 Wave

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
IPA Service

Connectivity Has Emerged As A Focus Area Of India And Bangladesh

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
IPA Service

BJP Led NDA Facing Toughest Test In Third Phase Of Assam Polls On April 6

by ipaadmin
April 3, 2021
Load More
Next Post

Children Rally Against Early Marriage

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

ADVERTISEMENT

Recommended

Samsung Galaxy A-series 2020 camera specifications leaked

Samsung Galaxy A-series 2020 camera specifications leaked

2 years ago

NPCIL Delivers Robust Performance During FY11-12

9 years ago
Load More
ADVERTISEMENT

Contact

India Press Agency D-34, Basement, Gulmohar Park, Delhi - 110049 Gautam Nagar, New Delhi
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

About Us

IPA Newspack

IPA Intelligence Unit is a specialist service of India Press Agency (IPA), one of the oldest news agencies of India.

  • Setup menu at Appearance » Menus and assign menu to Footer Navigation

© 2020 India Press Agency - Latest Breaking news and Opinion IPA Media Group | Arabian Post

No Result
View All Result

© 2020 India Press Agency - Latest Breaking news and Opinion IPA Media Group | Arabian Post

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In