Aggarwal said on Friday that VanDyke had been produced before a judge about six or seven times during his custody but had not alleged mistreatment. The comments followed VanDyke’s publication of allegations that he was assaulted and denied medical attention while detained for nearly six months.
The NIA chief distinguished the allegations against prison personnel from the conduct of the investigating agency. He said VanDyke had not accused NIA officers of assault and indicated that complaints made during court proceedings would have been examined. His remarks do not independently establish whether the alleged attacks occurred. Nor does the absence of a complaint during the cited hearings, by itself, resolve the dispute over conditions in the prison.
VanDyke, who was arrested with six Ukrainian nationals in March over alleged unauthorised travel through India into Myanmar, has accused prison staff of repeatedly attacking him. A handwritten affidavit prepared in August describes being punched in the chest, struck with a baton and deprived of urgently needed medical assistance for almost 24 hours.
The American posted the allegations publicly this month. He also claimed that his imprisonment and that of the Ukrainian defendants was connected to Russia’s war against Ukraine. No evidence establishing that alleged connection has emerged from the proceedings described by investigators, and the NIA has not accepted his account.
The affidavit, which VanDyke said he sent to the US embassy, was prepared before the agency submitted its chargesheet. He asked embassy officials to convey his concerns to authorities and indicated he might pursue legal and public disclosure of the alleged assaults. The allegations have not been adjudicated by a court. There has been no independently verified medical assessment or prison inquiry placed in the public domain that conclusively supports or refutes the account.
Aggarwal also addressed a separate question concerning the criminal investigation: why the NIA had not included terrorism offences in the chargesheet despite initially investigating the case under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, or UAPA.
He said investigators were examining data to establish whether any insurgent organisation from India had benefited from training allegedly provided by VanDyke and the six Ukrainians in Myanmar. The agency had not yet established the identities of alleged beneficiaries sufficiently to support additional charges, he said.
“We are sifting through it (data) to establish whether any Indian insurgent group benefited from their training. If we are able to establish that, we will chargesheet them,” Aggarwal said. His statement made clear that further prosecution under the UAPA remains conditional on evidence identifying the people allegedly trained.
The NIA maintains that the seven foreigners entered India on valid visas, travelled to Mizoram without the necessary permits, crossed into Myanmar by unauthorised routes and later returned through similar routes. Aggarwal said the investigation into their movements had been completed and charges filed on that aspect.
The chargesheet invokes Sections 21 and 23 of the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, rather than provisions of the anti-terrorism law. Investigators have kept the broader inquiry open and could file a supplementary chargesheet if they establish further offences. The allegations of militant training remain contested, and the defendants have not been convicted of those offences. The distinction between immigration violations and alleged terrorist activity is significant because the latter would require evidence supporting the statutory elements of a separate offence.
VanDyke was granted default bail after a court found the chargesheet insufficient to prevent his statutory release while the UAPA investigation remained unfinished. His release did not amount to a judicial finding that the entire prosecution case was unfounded.
The Delhi court subsequently allowed VanDyke and the Ukrainian defendants to remain abroad until 24 February 2027, when the matter is scheduled for further hearing. VanDyke returned to India once after securing bail to attend court proceedings, Aggarwal said.
The NIA arrested the seven at different airports after investigating their alleged movements across the Myanmar border. The agency has also examined whether the armed groups involved had connections with insurgent networks operating in India’s northeastern region. The precise identities of those allegedly trained remain a central unresolved issue in the still continuing investigation.
