Congress general secretary Jairam Ramesh said Modi’s questions to corporate leaders at the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FICCI) annual general meeting in New Delhi reflected problems the opposition had repeatedly highlighted. He argued that government decisions, rather than employers alone, were responsible for the conditions described by the Prime Minister.
Ramesh, writing on X after the address, said Modi had criticised industry leaders over their failure to expand employment and raise pay despite tax concessions. He accused the government of concentrating economic power, weakening competition and undermining confidence among potential investors.
“But the PM has been less than fair. His policies have led to this situation,” Ramesh said, disputing the suggestion that corporate decisions could be considered separately from the government’s economic record.
The dispute centred on whether tax relief alone could stimulate hiring and investment, or whether broader government policy was also shaping corporate decisions. The exchange followed Modi’s challenge to businesses to explain why reductions in taxes had not produced corresponding improvements in employment and wages. Speaking at Bharat Mandapam during FICCI’s centenary convention, he pointed to the reduction in the basic corporate tax rate from 30 per cent to 22 per cent and income tax relief for individuals earning up to Rs 12 lakh annually.
Modi asked whether employers had raised salaries or increased their workforce after benefiting from a more favourable tax environment. His remarks placed greater responsibility on companies to translate fiscal incentives and stronger purchasing power into jobs, employee earnings and investment.
The Prime Minister also defended the government’s economic programme, citing measures to simplify tax returns and refunds, reduce goods and services tax rates on numerous products and support domestic demand. He described India as the fastest-growing major economy and referred to growth projections of around seven per cent.
Ramesh countered that lower corporate taxes had not generated the investment expansion anticipated by the government. He said employment had failed to grow sufficiently and wages had not increased as expected, maintaining that the Prime Minister was effectively acknowledging criticisms raised by Congress.
“For the first time in 12 years, a nervous and rattled PM has pulled up the captains of industry,” Ramesh wrote. His description of Modi’s state of mind was a political characterisation rather than an independently established assessment.
The Congress leader further alleged that excessive concentration of market power had produced oligopolistic structures across industries. He claimed that this had restricted competition, while a climate of fear and intimidation discouraged businesses from undertaking fresh investment.
Ramesh also accused the government of allowing regulatory bodies to fall under the influence of favoured interests and using investigative agencies to benefit a particular conglomerate. Those accusations were not accompanied by independently established findings in his remarks, and he did not provide supporting evidence for the specific claims.
He linked difficulties faced by smaller businesses to the trade deficit with China, alleging that its expansion had damaged large numbers of micro, small and medium enterprises. Ramesh also criticised demonetisation and the structure of the goods and services tax, arguing that the policies had imposed additional burdens on economic activity.
The Congress maintained that inflation, insufficient employment growth and restrained private investment reflected both the substance and implementation of the government’s policies. Ramesh urged Modi to examine those choices instead of directing complaints towards industry leaders.
Modi’s address extended beyond wages and recruitment. He urged companies to reduce dependence on imported pharmaceutical ingredients and specialised metal products by investing in domestic manufacturing capacity and technology. He also pressed businesses to improve product quality and compete more vigorously in overseas markets.
He called on industry to use trade agreements to develop export opportunities, saying the domestic market should not become a comfort zone. Businesses, he argued, needed to understand foreign customers, meet international standards and establish distribution networks that could support sustained exports and job creation.
The Prime Minister identified agriculture, food processing, engineering tools and machinery as areas where companies could expand production and overseas sales. He also invited businesses to submit proposals for further reforms, saying the government remained open to suggestions even when they identified shortcomings.
