By Ashok Nilakantan Ayers
WASHINGTON: From the Manila Quad to the unprecedented Trump-Xi-Putin summit in Shenzhen, the American President returned proclaiming historic achievements. But beneath the spectacle of personal diplomacy lay unanswered questions about Ukraine, Iran, China, trade, nuclear disarmament and America’s credibility in the Indo-Pacific.
President Donald Trump returned to Washington on November 20 after a four-day Asian tour, confident that he had accomplished what previous American presidents had failed to achieve: bringing together the leaders of China and Russia with the United States in an unprecedented trilateral engagement. His 90-minute White House press conference was intended to sell the diplomatic successes of his journey to an American public increasingly concerned about inflation, the Iran war and the Republican Party’s recent midterm electoral reverses.
But the conference was as revealing for what Trump did not explain as for what he claimed to have achieved. It began with declarations about international peace and economic agreements, wandered into discussions about Air Force One, COVID vaccines, interest rates and domestic politics, and ended with an exchange in which he rebuked an NBC reporter and refused to take another question.
The central contradiction was evident throughout: Trump celebrated personal relationships with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin as instruments of global peace, yet produced few concrete assurances that these relationships had translated into enforceable agreements.
The centrepiece of Trump’s Asian tour was the first-ever three-way meeting of the American, Chinese and Russian presidents at Shenzhen, alongside the APEC summit. Trump described the encounter as historic, saying there was extraordinary chemistry between the three leaders. He argued that the world’s three largest nuclear powers had a special responsibility to prevent nuclear catastrophe and explore reductions in their nuclear arsenals.
Chinese President Xi Jinping called for preventing nuclear war and ultimately eliminating nuclear weapons. Putin spoke about common interests in resolving international conflicts, including Ukraine.
The three leaders issued a four-point peace declaration, including commitments relating to nuclear risks and stable energy supplies, particularly refined petroleum products.
Trump portrayed this as a major diplomatic achievement. He also said the discussions covered Ukraine and Iran, and claimed that Putin had told him Russia would never have invaded Ukraine had Trump been president in 2022.
There was no announced agreement on nuclear warhead reductions, no timetable for disarmament, no verifiable mechanism for monitoring compliance and no concrete roadmap for ending the Ukraine war. The declaration’s energy commitments also lacked specified quantities and implementation deadlines.
Trump insisted that Putin wanted peace and that his relationship with the Russian leader gave America additional strength. Yet Russia continued its military attacks on Ukraine after the meetings.
His description of Putin as a friend, and his assertion that the Russian president was having a difficult time with a war that should have lasted one day, raised another question: was Washington exercising influence over Moscow or normalising its conduct?
The optics were extraordinary. The American president sat with two leaders whose governments have frequently challenged American strategic interests, while presenting personal rapport as a substitute for the conventional diplomacy of agreements, verification and accountability.
Trump also announced a trade agreement with Thailand, although he did not provide comprehensive details of its terms. He encouraged ASEAN countries to cooperate with America on rare earths, critical minerals and magnets.
Yet the American president did not attend the East Asia Summit, a significant regional gathering. The US delegation there was led by Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs Allison Hooker.
This absence mattered. The East Asia Summit is one of the few forums bringing together major regional powers, including China, India, Japan, Russia and the United States.
The South China Sea disputes also remained unresolved. The long-awaited ASEAN-China code of conduct was not finalised, despite progress claimed by Philippine officials. When questioned about maritime tensions and the possibility of the US-Philippines Mutual Defense Treaty being invoked, Trump offered little strategic clarity, saying he was not concerned and that the matter would be taken care of.
For countries facing increasing Chinese maritime pressure, reassurance without an explicit explanation of American commitments may not be enough.
At the APEC summit in Shenzhen, the 21 member economies adopted the Shenzhen Outlook, focusing on resilient supply chains, digital trade, artificial intelligence, connectivity and development. Trump’s bilateral meeting with Xi also produced an agreement to work towards a framework for US-China strategic stability. But the most pressing economic issue remained unresolved: tariffs.
No new tariff reductions were announced, and the existing trade truce remained due to expire on January 10, 2027. Nor was there a comprehensive agreement on advanced semiconductor exports or China’s purchases of American agricultural products.
Trump spoke enthusiastically about future commercial opportunities and cooperation in AI. Yet the technology rivalry between Washington and Beijing remained intact. The APEC commitments themselves were largely voluntary, leaving their implementation to individual governments. (IPA Service)
