A three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant said the objections could be raised before the five-judge Constitution Bench constituted to examine the validity of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.
Bhushan had requested that the recall application be placed before Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma, who delivered the divided ruling. He argued that an alleged conflict of interest involving Justice Sharma required the original bench to reconsider its order referring the dispute to a larger bench.
The allegation concerns Justice Sharma’s son, who serves as standing counsel for the Election Commission of India before the Madhya Pradesh High Court. The application questions whether that professional connection created a conflict of interest. The allegation has not been judicially established.
Bhushan emphasised that Justice Sharma was due to retire at the end of the following week and pressed for the application to be heard before his retirement. He maintained that the request challenged the reference order itself, rather than merely raising an issue to be examined during arguments on the legislation.
Justice Joymalya Bagchi, who sat with the Chief Justice and Justice V Mohana, indicated that the Constitution Bench could consider the validity of the reference. The larger bench was not prevented from framing a question about whether the matter had properly been referred, he observed.
The Chief Justice also indicated that a recall application could be considered after a member of the original bench had retired. The court therefore did not accept the approaching retirement as grounds for an immediate, separate listing.
The exchanges did not settle the allegation of conflict of interest or determine the constitutional validity of the appointments law. They concerned the forum and timing for considering the procedural challenge. The petitioners retain the opportunity to advance their objection when the Constitution Bench hears the matter.
During the hearing, Bhushan argued that Justice Sharma’s opinion had been decisive in bringing about the reference. He suggested that without the disagreement between the two judges, there would have been no occasion to send the dispute to a larger bench.
The Chief Justice distinguished his administrative role in constituting the larger bench from the judicial opinions delivered in September. Bhushan clarified that he was not challenging the Chief Justice’s administrative action but seeking reconsideration of the order made by the original bench.
The September 23 ruling followed disagreement over whether the constitutional questions presented by the petitions required adjudication by five judges. Justice Datta considered a larger reference unnecessary, while Justice Sharma held that the issues merited consideration by a Constitution Bench.
The two judges nevertheless agreed that the matter should be placed before the Chief Justice for appropriate action. The dispute over the reference has now become an additional procedural question alongside the original challenge to the 2023 statute.
The legislation provides for appointments to the posts of Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners through a selection committee comprising the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister.
It replaced the Chief Justice of India on the selection committee with a Cabinet Minister. The preceding arrangement had been prescribed by the Supreme Court in March 2023, pending legislation by Parliament.
Petitioners, including the Association for Democratic Reforms, contend that the new arrangement gives the executive an overriding influence in choosing members of the Election Commission. They argue that this raises constitutional concerns about the independence of the body responsible for administering elections.
The Union government has defended the statutory framework against the constitutional challenge. The merits of those competing positions remain for judicial determination and were not decided during Friday’s brief hearing on the recall application.
The September proceedings also involved petitions brought by Jaya Thakur and other applicants challenging specific provisions of the Act. The contested provisions deal with the composition of the selection committee and the process governing appointments to the Election Commission. Their petitions also contest the exclusion of the Chief Justice from the selection process established under the contested legislation.
