By Dr. Arun Mitra
On 8 November 2026, Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited a CRPF camp in Karanpur, Bastar district, Chhattisgarh, on the occasion of Diwali and interacted with CRPF personnel, including women soldiers. During his address, he referred to “Intellectual Naxals,” alleging that they were influencing people against the Constitution and democratic institutions, and urged the security personnel to identify and defeat them. The women personnel also performed a dance, which the Prime Minister applauded.
The question that arises is whether it is appropriate for the Prime Minister to address security forces in this manner, portraying a particular ideological group as a target for them. Such an approach raises serious constitutional, ethical and professional concerns.
In his Independence Day address from the Red Fort on 15 August, the Prime Minister had also referred to “Intellectual Naxals,” claiming that Naxalism had been eliminated but that some people continued to exist in the form of Intellectual Naxals. This raises the question of whether the government is now more concerned about people who criticise it, question its policies or disagree with its ideology than about armed insurgency itself.
The Prime Minister’s style of communication is largely one-way. He rarely engages with journalists in a manner that allows critical questions to be asked and answered. Yet questioning the government is a fundamental democratic right. Labelling critics as “Intellectual Naxals” risks delegitimising dissent and undermining freedom of thought.
Recently, a Norwegian journalist, Helle Lyng, reportedly attempted to ask the Prime Minister questions relating to press freedom. Despite having a valid visa, she was allegedly prevented from attending a conference in Hyderabad. The incident came to light through a podcast and raises further concerns about the government’s attitude towards uncomfortable questions.
It is noteworthy that Narendra Modi did not hold conventional press conferences during twelve years as Prime Minister. Why does he avoid facing journalists and answering their questions?
Several claims made by him over the years have also attracted public scrutiny, including his remarks about gas being produced from drains and used for making tea, his suggestion that clouds could affect radar systems, his claim of having sold tea at a railway station, questions about his educational qualifications, and accounts of his foreign travels before becoming Chief Minister and Prime Minister. These are matters on which the public is entitled to seek clarity. No public office-holder should consider himself exempt from scrutiny.
Psychologically, this style of leadership has often been associated with narcissistic tendencies, in which the leader’s self-image becomes central and criticism is perceived as an attack. French psychologist Gustave Le Bon, in his book The Crowd, discussed how individuals in a crowd may abandon independent reasoning and become influenced by emotions, rumours and the authority of a leader. In such situations, repeated assertions can begin to be accepted as truth, patriotism can be defined according to the leader’s own terms, and critics can be branded anti-national.
History has witnessed how leaders such as Hitler and Mussolini cultivated unquestioning loyalty by appealing to emotions, glorifying themselves and portraying dissenters as enemies. When supporters begin attacking critics, falsehoods gain acceptance as truth and questioning the leader is treated as an offence, democracy is reduced to the exercise of power rather than the freedom of citizens.
The public has every right to question the government about the economy, inflation, rising petrol and diesel prices, the weakening rupee, unemployment and other pressing issues. Yet, when such questions are raised, supporters often respond, “What can Modi ji do?” Such blind defence of the leader prevents accountability and weakens democratic debate.
A country’s international standing is determined by its economic strength, political stability, diplomatic influence and the well-being of its people—not by the awards, ceremonial honours or grand receptions its leader receives abroad.
It is encouraging that sections of the younger generation are increasingly questioning government claims, examining facts and refusing to accept political narratives uncritically. This is a healthy sign for democracy. Citizens must be encouraged to think independently rather than follow leaders blindly.
The Prime Minister has also repeatedly sought to associate his personal image with different places, traditions and symbols. During the 2021 West Bengal Assembly election campaign, his appearance, including his beard, was widely compared with that of Rabindranath Tagore. Such image-building reflects the importance attached to personal projection in politics, but it cannot substitute for accountability and substantive governance.
The use of the expression “Intellectual Naxals” from the Red Fort was inappropriate for the dignity of the office of Prime Minister and for the spirit of national unity. Its use while addressing security personnel is even more concerning.
Security forces such as the CRPF are entrusted with protecting the Constitution, upholding the law and safeguarding all citizens. They are not instruments of any political party, leader or ideology. Their professional duty demands impartiality and political neutrality.
Any attempt to condition security forces to view political critics or ideological opponents as enemies is a dangerous development. It threatens to blur the distinction between the state and the ruling party, between constitutional duty and political loyalty.
Security forces must remain above politics. The effort to use them against ideological or political opponents is not merely inappropriate—it is a serious warning sign for democracy and the constitutional order. (IPA Service)
