By Nitya Chakraborty
The 90-minute trilateral summit at Shenzhen on Thursday November 19 attended by the Presidents of USA, China and Russia confirmed Chinese President Xi Jinping’s dominant position in present global diplomacy as he persuaded President Trump to agree to his four-point agenda for global peace and stability to be a part of the Shenzhen Declaration. The trilateral summit was not merely carefully choreographed optics by the Chinese hosts; in fact, the candid discussions brought the three leading powers of the world a bit closer as all three needed mutual assistance to tide over the present volatile situation unitedly.
The declaration was short, full of only the good intentions, but the most positive aspect of the trilateral declaration was the emphasis on dialogue and negotiations to avert an all-out nuclear war. Trump opened the talks by telling Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin that “we are making history”, that the U.S., China and Russia are uniquely placed to discuss their nuclear stockpiles and lowering the risks of such being used. Trump also said that peace could not be achieved by turning down opportunities for dialogue. Trump’s assertion had the tone of sincerity and it was adequately reciprocated by Xi and Putin.
The summit took place in the context of the current nuclear agreement between U.S. and Russia expiring in February 2027. Also, regarding trade talks, the present understanding between China and the U.S. on the export of critical minerals by China to the U.S. and export of AI chips to China by U.S. as per the last May summit agreement, expires in January 2027. So, both China and the U.S. needed thorough discussions to work out how the US-China trade momentum can be maintained despite the Nvidia controversy.
As far as Russia is concerned, Putin is depending on Trump to find out an escape route to get out of Ukraine war, with the present occupied provinces going to Russia under a new agreement. Despite Trump’s persuasion, Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelensky is not agreeing to the terms, as he is egged by the European powers to defy Trump and go on fighting Russia with European weapons and funds.
Much to the discomfiture of Trump, the 20 country heads of Europe along with the NATO secretary general Mark Rutte met in Berlin on the same day, i.e., November 19, to work out a plan for helping Ukraine. They worked on a funding programme for 2027. President Zelensky attended the meeting. In Shenzhen, on the other hand, even the American billionaire Elon Musk participated in mocking their Ukrainian policy, criticizing American involvement in the 2014 “Euromaidan coup”. So, Trump was quite not in a position to assure Putin about any viable formula which will be acceptable to Ukraine President. But Putin has no option. He has to depend on Trump for a face saver with dignity intact. Russian economy and the defence forces have been battered badly in nearly five years of war, while Ukraine is in literal ruins, with over a million Ukrainians killed in the war. It is better if the Ukraine war ends with Trump’s help.
All the issues of importance were taken up in three bilateral summits, which took place in Shenzhen on the eve of the trilateral summit. First, there was a meeting between Xi and Putin to work out a common strategy to deal with Trump. This was followed by a meeting between Trump and Xi, which discussed the trade issues focusing mainly on the continuation of the present arrangement for export of AI chips to China. Though China has initiated talks with South Korea for alternate supplies, but the US chips are essential at this stage for Chinese high-tech industry. Xi and Trump tried to work out a compromise formula. This will be followed further in the next round of talks at Miami, when President Xi attends the G20 summit on December 14 and 15.
In Trump’s bilateral meeting with Putin, Ukraine war and the nuclear agreement were on the agenda, but most attention was on Ukraine war. Putin expressed his anxiety at the European powers meet in Berlin and how it would encourage Zelensky to defy any proposal mooted by Trump. The outcome of the recent talks in Abu Dhabi between Russian and Ukraine officials was reviewed. Trump could not give any guarantee to Putin on ending the war on Russian President’s terms.
The trilateral summit is being touted by Chinese media as a big success of the Chinese line of creating a world with rule-based international order. China took the initiative for the summit as against the cool stance of the U.S. state department. The Chinese official media was the first to issue the text of the Shenzhen Declaration. The White House for long did not react. Trump left for airport as soon as the summit ended, without making any comment to press. It was all a grand show of China to prove that President Xi Jinping is the supremo of global diplomacy in the present period of declining American power.
President Xi made four points at the summit on how major countries could find the right way to get along and jointly underpin world peace. Major countries should uphold mutual respect, peaceful coexistence, win-win cooperation as also dialogue and consultation, Xi said. The Chinese President mentioned that China, Russia and United States should be partners and friends, they should not go for conflict and confrontation among themselves.
The right vibe for ensuring mutual cooperation was there at the trilateral summit. It is to be seen now how this cooperative spirit is carried forward in the coming months to solve the issues of Ukraine war and the Iran-Israel confrontation. (IPA Service)
