Rashidi challenges Javed Akhtar over remarks on Ram

IPA Staff
6 Min Read
Lyricist Javed Akhtar’s description of Lord Ram as a moral ideal shared across religions has drawn criticism from cleric Maulana Sajid Rashidi, who questioned his motives and suggested that he change his name to Ram Pal.

Rashidi, president of the All India Imam Association, challenged Akhtar’s comments on Tuesday, accusing the veteran screenwriter of invoking Ram to protect his commercial interests in the film industry. His allegations concerned Akhtar’s intentions rather than any specific business transaction, and no evidence was offered to substantiate them.

Akhtar had told journalists in Mumbai that Ram represented more than a religious figure, describing him as an embodiment of morality, cultural sensibility and a way of living. He said the values associated with Ram extended beyond the boundaries of individual faiths.

“Many people may be angry with me, but the essence of Ram runs in the blood of every Indian, irrespective of religion,” Akhtar said. He added that although Ram was personified as an individual, he represented something much larger: a way of life.

Rashidi objected to those assertions, pointing to Akhtar’s publicly stated atheism. He argued that someone who had repeatedly rejected religious belief should explain why he was now speaking so admiringly about Ram. The cleric presented Akhtar’s words as an expression of religious devotion, although Akhtar had framed his remarks around ethics and cultural identity.

“I have a suggestion for him: change your name from Javed Akhtar to Ram Pal,” Rashidi said. He also suggested that Akhtar would gain greater acceptance among Hindu audiences by adopting such a position, a contention that reflected the cleric’s personal interpretation of the writer’s comments.

Rashidi further alleged that Akhtar’s family connections to film production and songwriting influenced his public statements. He claimed that praise of religious figures could help artists retain audiences and sell their work. Those claims were not supported by independently established evidence linking the remarks to any commercial decision.

The exchange followed Akhtar’s appearance at the launch of a music creators’ report by the Indian Performing Right Society in Mumbai on Tuesday. Questions about the film Ramayana and Akhtar’s lyrics for the 2004 film Swades prompted his observations about the cultural significance of Ram.

One question concerned the song Pal Pal Hai Bhaari, written by Akhtar for director Ashutosh Gowariker’s Swades, starring Shah Rukh Khan. Its lyrics include the line “Mann se Raavan jo nikaale, Ram uske mann mein hai”, expressing the idea that overcoming evil within oneself makes room for Ram.

Akhtar explained the song’s appeal by describing Ram as an ideal rather than merely a person. “Ram is not just a person, Ram is an ideal, a morality, Ram is a way of living,” he said, adding that the figure also represented certain aesthetic and ethical values that could touch people across religious identities.

The songwriter had initially responded with humour when asked why his words continued to resonate with listeners. “The simple explanation is that I’m a good writer, let’s start from here,” he said, before elaborating on the meaning behind the song.

Congress politician Udit Raj, asked about Akhtar’s remarks, said individuals were entitled to interpret religious texts from their own perspectives. Samajwadi Party MP Rajiv Rai likewise stressed the importance of allowing people to express differing views, while describing the Ramayana as sacred to Hindus. Neither politician endorsed Rashidi’s allegation that Akhtar had spoken for financial advantage, and defended differing interpretations.

The disagreement has also focused attention on the distinction between appreciating a religious tradition’s ethical teachings and personally professing religious faith. Akhtar has openly identified as an atheist, and his comments at the Mumbai event did not include an announcement that he had changed his beliefs or adopted religious observance.

Akhtar, 81, also discussed Nitesh Tiwari’s screen adaptation of the Ramayana. He said he had not watched the film, although his daughter, filmmaker Zoya Akhtar, had seen it and spoken positively about it. He joked that her praise carried weight because she was difficult to impress and rarely complimented his own work.

The adaptation features Ranbir Kapoor as Ram, Sai Pallavi as Sita and Yash as Ravana. Akhtar’s discussion of the production arose alongside questions about how Hindi cinema draws upon established literary and cultural stories. He also remarked on the industry’s preference for broadly appealing formulas rather than adaptations of literary works.

TAGGED:
Share This Article