Supreme Court sustains Azam Khan conviction stay, extends relief

IPA Staff
5 Min Read
The Supreme Court on Tuesday dismissed the Uttar Pradesh government’s challenge to a stay on Samajwadi Party leader Azam Khan’s conviction in a forged birth certificate case and extended the same protection to his wife and son.

A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu upheld the Allahabad High Court’s May 24, 2024, decision concerning Khan while allowing separate appeals by his wife, Tazeen Fatma, and son, Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan. Their convictions will also remain suspended while their criminal revision petitions are pending before the High Court.

The ruling removes the distinction the High Court had drawn between the three family members. Although it suspended all three prison sentences and granted bail, the High Court had stayed only Azam Khan’s conviction, declining equivalent relief to his wife and son.

The Supreme Court held that the High Court had not adequately explained why people convicted in the same alleged conspiracy, on substantially identical evidence, should receive different interim treatment. It described that unequal approach as a violation of the principle of parity and an error of jurisdiction.

The judgment invoked constitutional guarantees of equality and personal dignity, noting that arbitrary differences in the treatment of similarly placed defendants can have consequences while their challenges to convictions remain undecided.

The judges also rejected the state government’s contention that the High Court had improperly granted Azam Khan relief beyond what he had sought. The record showed that applications seeking stays of conviction had been filed separately, alongside requests to suspend the sentences.

Additional Solicitor General K M Nataraj, appearing for Uttar Pradesh, argued that the High Court had failed to give distinct reasons for suspending Khan’s conviction. Senior advocate Kapil Sibal represented the three family members and contested the state’s objections.

The Supreme Court found the High Court’s reasoning sufficient, pointing to its consideration of Khan’s period in custody, age and the absence of direct evidence that he personally forged signatures in municipal registers. It held there was no compelling ground to interfere with that exercise of discretion under Article 136 of the Constitution.

The bench nevertheless emphasised that staying a conviction is an exceptional measure, different from suspending a prison sentence. Suspension of sentence postpones punishment pending judicial review, whereas a stay of conviction temporarily halts the legal consequences flowing from a finding of guilt.

The judgment said such discretion must be exercised consistently, while taking account of the consequences for individuals and the public interest. Courts could distinguish between co-convicts where the evidence justified it, but any material difference had to be clearly identified and explained.

The judges also rejected the idea that electoral considerations alone could justify an order staying a conviction. They said statutory judicial powers could not be employed merely to accommodate political ambitions or election timetables.

The decision does not overturn the underlying convictions or decide whether the accused committed the offences. Those questions remain before the Allahabad High Court, which has been directed to determine the pending revision petitions independently and as expeditiously as possible, without being influenced by the Supreme Court’s observations.

A Rampur trial court convicted the three in October 2023 and sentenced them to seven years’ imprisonment in a case involving allegations of cheating, forgery and criminal conspiracy. An appellate court affirmed the convictions in December that year, after which the family sought relief before the High Court.

The prosecution case arose from a complaint concerning two birth certificates for Abdullah Azam Khan. Investigators alleged that documents issued in Rampur and Lucknow recorded conflicting dates and places of birth. The allegations formed the basis of a case registered at Ganj police station in Rampur in January 2019.

The Supreme Court noted that the prosecution relied on a common allegation of conspiracy and the same disputed documents against all three defendants. It found no separately attributed act of physically forging documents by Fatma or Abdullah beyond their alleged roles as co-conspirators and beneficiaries.

The bench observed that a conviction can affect reputation and personal dignity while legal proceedings remain unresolved. It said courts considering interim relief must balance potential irreversible harm against the importance of preserving the authority of criminal convictions until they are set aside.

The parties agreed to cooperate with the High Court bench hearing their revision petitions to facilitate an early disposal of those proceedings.

TAGGED:
Share This Article