A bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi issued the direction on Tuesday during criminal contempt proceedings brought by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) over remarks concerning Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and the courts. Raut appeared personally, while journalist Nikhil Wagle, also named in the proceedings, attended virtually.
The judges asked both men to file additional affidavits addressing the statements cited against them and ordered them to attend the next hearing in person on December 8. The court did not decide whether either respondent had committed contempt.
Addressing Raut, Justice Kumar said he was a seasoned politician whose speeches the judge had followed since his days as a lawyer. As an experienced parliamentarian, Raut should understand the restraint expected in public statements, the judge observed.
The bench also questioned whether Raut’s apology adequately addressed his conduct. Justice Kumar said an apology in a matter of this nature should come from the heart rather than the mind, indicating that the court wanted a fuller explanation before considering his position.
SCBA president and senior advocate Pradeep Rai argued that Raut had continued posting material critical of the judiciary after expressing regret. Rai cited statements alleging that the Bharatiya Janata Party controlled the judiciary, investigating agencies and the Election Commission, along with a post depicting a fire at Albania’s Supreme Court.
Rai submitted that the image and accompanying remarks carried an implied reference to India’s Supreme Court. He also questioned why Raut’s earlier affidavit did not address those posts. The allegations were made by the association and were not findings recorded against Raut by the bench.
Raut’s counsel said he was not defending the remarks and maintained that his client had tendered an unconditional apology and undertaken not to repeat the conduct. Counsel agreed that a further affidavit could be submitted and asked the judges to consider Raut’s treatment for cancer and heart ailments.
The court nevertheless declined a request to excuse Raut from attending the next hearing. Its direction for a further affidavit leaves him an opportunity to respond specifically to the additional posts relied upon by the association.
The bench separately examined Wagle’s position after senior advocate Indira Jaising submitted that the journalist had deleted the offending post, acknowledged his mistake and apologised unconditionally to the Chief Justice and the Supreme Court. She requested that he be discharged from the proceedings.
Jaising argued that Wagle was not attempting to justify his language. She also raised the legal distinction between an offensive remark directed at a judge and conduct amounting to criminal contempt, urging the bench to assess the context rather than treating every insult as contempt automatically.
The judges required Wagle to provide a further affidavit addressing the precise wording of his social media post. Justice Kumar observed that journalists have responsibilities associated with their position as members of the fourth estate. The court also directed Wagle to attend physically on December 8, notwithstanding his counsel’s request for exemption.
The association initiated the case after remarks made following Chief Justice Surya Kant’s decision not to meet an opposition delegation seeking to discuss concerns about the functioning of the Election Commission. The Chief Justice had indicated that such grievances should be brought before the court through appropriate legal proceedings.
The SCBA sought action over Wagle’s abusive online message and statements attributed to Raut concerning judges and alleged political associations. Those statements included a claim about judges playing badminton with political figures in London, which the association described as false. The proceedings concern whether the disputed expressions cross the legal threshold for criminal contempt.
Attorney General R Venkataramani granted the consent required for the SCBA to pursue the petition under Section 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971. The court issued notices to the respondents in October and subsequently required their participation in the hearing.
After hearing the parties, the matter is listed for December 8 at 2 pm, when the court is expected to consider the supplementary affidavits. Both respondents have been instructed to attend personally rather than through video conferencing. The earlier hearing had permitted Wagle to participate remotely.
