By Tirthankar Mitra
KOLKATA: Manoj Kumar Oraon, forest minister in the six-month old BJP government of West Bengal has drawn ridicule after seeking “loan” of 500 police personnel for deploying in different forests of the state. Oraon has written to chief minister, Suvendu Adhikari who is in charge of the police department asking for the requisite number of policemen.
This is the first BJP state government whose writ runs over West Bengal. And except Adhikari who headed several departments in the previous Trinamool Congress dispensation, the other ministers lack administrative exposure.
Oraon’s missive to the chief minister has evoked barely concealed titters in the administrative circle. For it seeks to fit square pegs in round holes. Duties of policemen and foresters are as different from each other as chalk is to cheese. The policemen maintain law and order while forest department personnel are entrusted to upkeep of the forest which includes preventing poaching and illegal felling of trees.
Both departments are short staffed. While chief minister Adhikari has announced recruitment of policemen in near future, no such announcement has been forthcoming from his Cabinet colleague looking after the forest affairs.
As for the state forest department, posts of a few thousand beat officers and about two thousand forest guards are lying vacant. Daily wage workers are vainly trying to fill up the gaps.
The ineptitude of the forest department personnel came under the scanner in the wake of a tigress slipping out of Buxa Tiger Reserve. Drawing flak from the Union Ministry of forest and environment, some of the senior officials of the state forest department advised the minister to seek constables and assistant sub inspectors from the state police force.
Forest minister Orao is a legislator from Kumargram in north Bengal. This part of the state is dotted with forests of which Buxa is one. His origin and constituency may acquaint him well with flora and fauna of the forests. But Oraon’s administrative inexperience is exposed.
The forest minister has sought 100 ASIs and 400 constables. That the chief minister is unresponsive to this strange request can be gauged from the fact that police department has not received any “deputation” for transferring its personnel.
Of late, the police department seems to have been besieged by strange “requests”. Earlier, state higher education minister, Jagannath Chattopadhyay said that every police station should organise worship of goddess Kali.
One is in the dark whether it has been binned. But the fact remains that no worship of the goddess have been reported from any police station of the state.
But the state police department seems to have no respite. Oraon stepped in seeking the help of men in uniform to stop straying of elephant herds and leopard attacks, both common occurrences in the part of the state he hails from.
And the minister has reasons for worrying as elephant herds are likely to lumber into crop fields in larger numbers as the season for reaping paddy. Moreover, cash crunch in the forest department stand in the way of recruitment.
Deployment of some policemen accompanying forest department personnel to tackle a law and order problem or trafficking wild life apparently triggered minister Oraon’s request. But it raises questions about the wisdom of those who inducted him in the state Cabinet.
Belonging to the tribal community and representing a north Bengal constituency seems to have tipped the scale in his favour. But the powers that be who green flagged his induction in the Cabinet, overlooked his lack of knowledge in administrative affairs.
It also exposes Oraon being out of touch with officers who would have prevented him from making himself a laughing stock. Nobody drew his attention that forest department personnel enjoy certain powers of seizure and interrogation of arrested persons under Indian Forest Act and Wildlife Protection Act.
Policemen on deputation are unlikely to enjoy such powers. Moreover, forest department personnel are in a higher grade of service than policemen.
The forest department personnel have to go through specialised courses in a span of two years. This will put the policemen who have not gone through them but deployed in forest management at a disadvantage.
Oraon’s letter to chief minister, Adhikari overlooks all these and more. It is indeed a pointer that some of ministers in the newly elected BJP government are finding shoes read respective departments too big for their feet read administrative capacity. (IPA Service)
