Singh’s rejoinder, filed on November 15, describes the Commission’s response as a “bureaucratic cover-up” and asks the court to examine original records showing who authorised actions undertaken in the poll body’s name. The filing contests affidavits dated October 26 and November 14 and maintains that later agreement among commissioners cannot retrospectively establish approval for earlier administrative decisions.
“Unanimity in defending an act is not unanimity in deciding it,” the petitioner says, distinguishing the Commission’s collective defence of its conduct from the statutory requirement governing its decisions.
The dispute centres on Section 18 of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023. It provides for decisions by consensus where possible and majority vote where commissioners differ. Singh argues that officials cannot exercise powers reserved for the three-member constitutional body without valid delegation.
The Commission rejects suggestions of unilateral decision-making. Its October affidavit says the principal SIR orders of June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025 and May 14, 2026 were approved unanimously. It also says its affidavit was endorsed by Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi.
Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu affirmed the Commission’s affidavits. The poll body says members’ observations and questions on files are part of deliberations rather than binding decisions, while statutory provisions and standing orders permit designated officers to perform delegated functions. It says urgent approvals may be obtained electronically and recorded on files afterwards, without requiring a physical meeting of commissioners.
Singh disputes that explanation, identifying 20 statements in the Commission’s filings which, he contends, reveal actions by officials or divisions without decisions recorded by the full Commission. He wants the original files, approval sheets, meeting records and electronic audit trails produced so the court can distinguish authorised decisions from subsequent explanations.
One contested issue concerns an additional declaration incorporated into the online Form 6 process during the electoral revision. Singh contends that applicants had to provide information linking themselves or relatives to earlier electoral rolls although changes to the statutory form require legal authority. The Commission maintains that Form 6 itself was never amended and that the declaration was separate.
The petitioner says the Commission’s decision to separate the declaration from the online form on October 21 does not resolve whether its earlier use was authorised. He also questions whether objections recorded by the two Election Commissioners were properly reflected in the eventual administrative action.
Another dispute concerns appeals filed by electoral officials in West Bengal against findings that certain voters were eligible. Singh says the Commission acknowledged that these appeals were not placed before the three members and asks whether any lawful delegation authorised their filing. The Commission’s position on its wider delegation arrangements remains part of the contested proceedings.
The rejoinder also challenges the geographical scope of relief offered to electors omitted from draft rolls. Singh points to directions issued on November 6 to seven states and Union Territories and asks why equivalent opportunities were not extended across all areas undergoing the revision.
Those directions allow certain excluded electors to submit enumeration forms and provide for restoration of their earlier voter identification numbers following verification. The Commission says the measures were designed to prevent eligible electors being excluded while guarding against duplicate enrolment.
Its November 14 affidavit further clarifies that people omitted during the revision will not face prosecution merely because they submit Form 6 despite having appeared on earlier rolls, provided they are not registered elsewhere and their declarations otherwise comply with the law.
Singh has asked the court to require identification of the authority, date and recorded approval supporting each challenged action. He also seeks preservation of relevant files and electronic records, alongside procedures ensuring that future Commission decisions are properly documented.
The petition, registered as a civil writ proceeding against the Union of India and others, is listed before Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana on November 17. The Supreme Court permitted further affidavits when it considered the connected petitions on October 27.
